Wicked Wanderings

Ep. 19: Part 1 - Under the Radar The Covert Horrors of a Modern Murderer

January 10, 2024 Jess and Hannah Season 1 Episode 19
Ep. 19: Part 1 - Under the Radar The Covert Horrors of a Modern Murderer
Wicked Wanderings
More Info
Wicked Wanderings
Ep. 19: Part 1 - Under the Radar The Covert Horrors of a Modern Murderer
Jan 10, 2024 Season 1 Episode 19
Jess and Hannah

Send us a Text Message.

Prepare to be gripped by the harrowing account of a killer who eluded the spotlight yet orchestrated some of the most methodical and bone-chilling crimes of the century. Our latest episode unveils the terrifying and true chronicles of Israel Keyes, a name that may not ring bells like Bundy or Dahmer, but whose dark legacy is equally disturbing. Using “American Predator" by Maureen Callahan for our research , we explore the twisted world of a man whose life was a macabre tapestry of isolation, extremism, and cold-blooded murder. The unsettling saga of Samantha Koenig's abduction from a peaceful Anchorage coffee kiosk will leave you questioning the very nature of evil, as we recount the calculated steps Keyes took to execute his plan and the shocking aftermath that unfolded.

As the narrative unfolds, the staggering missteps of Keyes that led to his downfall offer a chilling lesson in the arrogance of criminal confidence. The painstaking efforts of law enforcement, the anguish of a father searching for his daughter, and the surreal staging of a most morbid ransom demand, paint a picture of desperation and deceit. We tread carefully through the early warning signs in Keyes' life, from his extremist upbringing to his disturbing behaviors, and dissect the investigation that pierced his veil of secrecy. This episode is a testament to the perseverance of those who relentlessly pursue justice, and a sobering reminder of the monsters who walk among us.

***Merch Store***

Support the Show.

If you'd like to show your support for Wicked Wanderings and join our community of dedicated listeners, you can start contributing for as little as $3 a month. Your support helps us continue to explore the darkest and most intriguing mysteries, bringing you captivating stories from the world of true crime and the unexplained. Click the link to become a valued member of our podcast family.

Don't forget to rate, review, and follow us on your favorite streaming platform.
Wicked Wanderings Website
Linktree
Instagram
Hannah's Bookstagram
Jess's Bookstagram

We'd love to hear from you! If you have any questions or suggestions please feel free to email us @ wickedwanderingspodcast@gmail.com.

Wicked Wanderings is hosted by Hannah Fitzpatrick and Jess Goonan. It is produced and edited by Rob Fitzpatrick. Music by Sascha Ende. Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 Lic.

WickedWanderingsPlus
Exclusive access to bonus episodes!
Starting at $3/month Subscribe
Show Notes Transcript Chapter Markers

Send us a Text Message.

Prepare to be gripped by the harrowing account of a killer who eluded the spotlight yet orchestrated some of the most methodical and bone-chilling crimes of the century. Our latest episode unveils the terrifying and true chronicles of Israel Keyes, a name that may not ring bells like Bundy or Dahmer, but whose dark legacy is equally disturbing. Using “American Predator" by Maureen Callahan for our research , we explore the twisted world of a man whose life was a macabre tapestry of isolation, extremism, and cold-blooded murder. The unsettling saga of Samantha Koenig's abduction from a peaceful Anchorage coffee kiosk will leave you questioning the very nature of evil, as we recount the calculated steps Keyes took to execute his plan and the shocking aftermath that unfolded.

As the narrative unfolds, the staggering missteps of Keyes that led to his downfall offer a chilling lesson in the arrogance of criminal confidence. The painstaking efforts of law enforcement, the anguish of a father searching for his daughter, and the surreal staging of a most morbid ransom demand, paint a picture of desperation and deceit. We tread carefully through the early warning signs in Keyes' life, from his extremist upbringing to his disturbing behaviors, and dissect the investigation that pierced his veil of secrecy. This episode is a testament to the perseverance of those who relentlessly pursue justice, and a sobering reminder of the monsters who walk among us.

***Merch Store***

Support the Show.

If you'd like to show your support for Wicked Wanderings and join our community of dedicated listeners, you can start contributing for as little as $3 a month. Your support helps us continue to explore the darkest and most intriguing mysteries, bringing you captivating stories from the world of true crime and the unexplained. Click the link to become a valued member of our podcast family.

Don't forget to rate, review, and follow us on your favorite streaming platform.
Wicked Wanderings Website
Linktree
Instagram
Hannah's Bookstagram
Jess's Bookstagram

We'd love to hear from you! If you have any questions or suggestions please feel free to email us @ wickedwanderingspodcast@gmail.com.

Wicked Wanderings is hosted by Hannah Fitzpatrick and Jess Goonan. It is produced and edited by Rob Fitzpatrick. Music by Sascha Ende. Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 Lic.

Hannah:

You want your best out of three. Yeah, all right, let's do it. Ready. Rock paper scissors shoot. Rock paper scissors shoot Damn girl Wow.

Jess:

Is this what you did in the military? No, all right. Let me tell you what I did in the military.

Hannah:

Oh, it's like she knew what I was going to do. I read your mind.

Jess:

Ok, hello wanderers, I'm Jess.

Hannah:

And.

Jess:

I'm Hannah and welcome to Wicked Wanderings Hello.

Hannah:

Hannah, hello Jess, how's it going? Oh, it's going.

Jess:

How are you it's going? We are back at it again, talking about some douche canoes. Yes, I know it's everybody's favorite subject, which is why we have a podcast. So this case is a serial killer and probably one of the most prolific serial killers in the country. However, nobody has heard of him.

Hannah:

Yeah, when you Barely anybody. When you were mentioning him, I was like who the fuck is that?

Jess:

Yeah, so we're going to talk about major douche canoes, israel keys. The one thing that we should know is that, for Israel keys, his idol was Ted Bundy, so I mean if that kind of tells you the kind of douche canoes we use right.

Hannah:

It's like those people that really have a thing for Adolf Hitler. You start to worry about a little bit, you know.

Jess:

Well, and what I didn't realize before researching obviously is there may or may not be some domestic terrorism ties with Israel keys as well.

Hannah:

What.

Jess:

Yeah, I was shocked when I heard that.

Hannah:

Israel is such an interesting name. It is. Do you know?

Jess:

why he's called Israel. His family, as I'll talk about, was very involved in a lot of extremist religions. Ok, and really he was born in Utah, which I'll talk about, which I didn't even realize.

Hannah:

Oh my goodness, because you were saying like, all right, we need to get away from Utah and Massachusetts.

Jess:

And here we are, and then here I am talking about someone who was born in Utah, but my main source for this episode is American Predator the hunt for the most meticulous serial killer of the 21st century, by Maureen Callahan, and I listened to the audio book and that was pretty good.

Hannah:

Yeah, so would you recommend the book? Yes for sure. Ok, so if we really like the book we research from, I think we should recommend because we are a book people too. Yeah, I think that'd be good. Like would you recommend this book to add something to it?

Jess:

Yes, and so the reason I like this book is because she interviews the FBI agents that were involved. She interviews the police detectives that were involved in the investigations and she also has some of the transcripts from the interviews. So, and then at the end she'll say her sources like, hey, this is where I've gotten my information and she had a lawyer involved to get some of the information Interesting. Yeah, so it's pretty cool because a lot of this hasn't really been released, and you'll find out why in our second episode.

Hannah:

Oh Well, you've captivated me, yes.

Jess:

So shortly after 7 PM on February 1st 2012, 18-year-old Samantha Koenig was working alone at a coffee kiosk in Anchorage, alaska, called Coffee Grounds, and this was just like a small shack on the side of a busy road and just had like drive through or walk up. And she that night was fighting with her boyfriend Dwayne through texts in the middle of her orders. And what year is this? This is 2012. Ok, so pretty recent yeah very recent.

Jess:

Absolutely. She was fighting with her boyfriend because she caught him flirting with other girls, and rightfully so. She got a little upset, yeah, as we all would. So a man who would later be identified as, like I said, major Douche Canoe, israel Keys, came up to the window and ordered an Americano, and when Samantha handed over the coffee, keys pulled out a gun and told her to hand over the money in the register. She does that, and then he tells her to turn off the lights in the kiosk. He has her back up to the window, to the window to the walls.

Hannah:

Beep, beep, beep down my balls. Oh see, I was beeping it out and she's like let's talk about them balls, sorry mom.

Jess:

So he pulled out a gun, told her to hand over the money in the register. She does that and he tells her to turn off the lights in the kiosk and back up to the window.

Hannah:

To the wall.

Jess:

Yes, so he can tie her hands behind her back and then tells her to kneel on the floor and kind of move out of the way. Then Keys climbs through the window. They talk for a few minutes. He asks her some questions. Did she push the alarm? No, she said. He asked her if she was being truthful because he was actually wearing earpiece with the police radio when he was listening to it in his ear.

Hannah:

He told her so wait, there was actually a button in this small kiosk. I was not picturing. I see that in big jewelry stores and stuff.

Jess:

But interesting and from what I've read, that these little kiosks are a good target for robberies because they're kind of out of the way.

Hannah:

Especially in Alaska, like it is.

Jess:

Anchorage but still Alaska. And this night the kiosk was kind of surrounded by five feet drifts or like snow plow piles.

Jess:

And so there was kind of a lot of privacy for him to do this. He told her he would kill her if he hears anything. She assured him that she didn't. He's asked what her name was and she told him and said her dad would be there any minute, even though he wasn't due to show up for like a half hour. He told her they were going for a walk and he walks with her across the busy street to the Home Depot parking lot and as they were walking, Keys finds a camera on the ground and it took his attention off Samantha for a moment. So it was like a Canon camera that he found and he wanted to sell and so she took this opportunity to run. But he was able to tackle her and regained control by pressing a 22 is 22 pistol against her ribs.

Hannah:

I'm actually going to look up a picture of him now because I'm curious.

Jess:

Yeah, he threatened to kill her if she tried to escape again, and there were people around in cars at the intersection, but either no one noticed or they just were minding their own business.

Hannah:

He's so young.

Jess:

Yeah, he was 34.

Hannah:

Wow, sorry that. Just he's so young. I don't know why that surprised me, because like Ted Bundy was young.

Jess:

Yeah.

Hannah:

So I don't know Interesting yeah.

Jess:

Like I said, either no one noticed or they just minded their own business or knew that there was a kidnapping in progress. They made it through the Home Depot parking lot to where his white truck was parked in the IHOT parking lot. There was actually a car parked next to his truck and there were people outside talking again, and he threatened Samantha again as they get in his truck and he opens the door for him, puts on her seatbelt and these people too leave without knowing what's going on. They stop at an intersection and a police cruiser pulls up next to them. Ooh, ooh, ooh, good news. And Samantha is threatened again to not say anything.

Jess:

Keys has the police radio in his ear, like I said, and Samantha can also hear the radio from the cruiser and it almost seems like she's weighing out her options. Would they be able to see her? Would they be able to hear her? And what if they don't? What will he do to me? She doesn't say anything in hopes that Keys will eventually let her go.

Jess:

He drives around for hours and he tells her that he is kidnapping her for ransom and she tells him that her family doesn't have any money and he assures her that her family will be able to raise some money.

Jess:

And at one point during the drive he realized that she didn't have her cell phone, which was an important part of his plan for ransom.

Jess:

So they drove back to the kiosk, sorry to get her cell phone, and he left her tied up in the truck and he uses Samantha's phone to text Dwayne, acting as Samantha, telling him that she needs a vacation and she needs to take some time to think.

Jess:

So they drove around some more and he ended up taking her to a park near his home and there were people there as well. He and Samantha smoked a cigar and he helped her, since her arms were still tied behind her back and he wasn't sure if anyone noticed him, but no one did anything. If they did, he ties her up and tells her to lay down in the back seat, so he ties her legs or feet and Samantha's shaking, so he put some blankets over her and threatens her again to make sure she doesn't scream. He notices that she's low on gas, so he stops to get gas where there are people around too, and it's like Keys holds her captive in plain sight and scares her into silence when there's people around. So many times. There are so many times where, like she could have screamed out and people could have helped.

Hannah:

So you know, maybe it's because of all the true crime and the podcast and all of the reading I do, but I think about that. Sometimes. I look around me. I'm like how many people need help right now? And they can't. Like that's my mindset, and I know that's not everyone's mindset, but like you're in you know, a pride station or whatever, because pride is what we have around this area, and I'm like, does anyone need help? Am I not looking in the right spot?

Jess:

But what would you do, Like what would happen if this person has a gun? Oh my God, I don't know right.

Hannah:

I mean as a person captive, or as a person that can help. That could help, I don't know. I'd like to think that I would do the right thing, yeah, but when you're in that moment that's petrifying.

Jess:

Yeah, I was just listening to a podcast on crime junkie about the her president's episode on why 911 was created and it was because this girl had gotten attacked in like an apartment complex and she was screaming and people heard her. I can't remember her name, but he stabbed her and then a guy yelled out the window like hey, leave that girl alone. So the attacker took off and then he waited around for 10 minutes. She's like walking to her apartment and she's like dying on the stairs bleeding out, and the attacker comes back and sexually assaults her and continues to stab her and there's people that hear this going on and nobody calls the police.

Hannah:

I can't imagine an error where there's no 911. I never would think about that, which, by the way, I believe in the UK it's 999. Am I right?

Jess:

You know what I don't know. I say yes, like I know, I know everything.

Hannah:

You are correct.

Jess:

Okay, Thanks.

Hannah:

Rob. Also, their sirens is different, but that's another story. I hope no one ever has to use it, but I have to say, dylane, 911 is petrifying. I've had to do it, jess. Have you had to do it? I don't know. It's the adrenaline's going, for whatever reason it might be. If you see something, say something, people, that's the words takeaway, words of wisdom from Hannah. Come back for the other episodes.

Jess:

So Keyes finally takes her to his house Well, it's his girlfriend's house and leaves her in the truck as he goes into the house to see if his girlfriend and his 10-year-old daughter are asleep.

Hannah:

Oh, my God.

Jess:

He then comes outside and starts to prep the shed that's next to the driveway. He tinkers around there until 1 am. When he gets Samantha out of the truck and takes her into the shed, he assured her that he was going to ask for ransom and then she'd be let go. Samantha gave him her address so he could get a hold of her dad for the ransom, and she also told him where to find her debit card in her truck, at her house. You're going to think this is crazy.

Jess:

Keyes left Samantha tied up in the shed, then drove to her house and as he was digging through the truck looking for the debit card, samantha's boyfriend, dwayne, randomly comes out of the house and sees Keyes going through the truck. What the flying fuck? The two men stare at each other for probably a few seconds, but it probably seemed like longer and then Dwayne runs back into the house Some sources say it was to go get help but Keyes, having the debit card, takes off and goes to the ATM and he realizes that he forgot the pin number. So he drives back to his house to get the pin from Samantha, then goes back to the ATM to test the pin to make sure that she gave him the right one. So there's a lot of movement in this scenario. It really is, and usually he is more meticulous than that, has more of a plan, so I don't know what it was about this night that.

Hannah:

Because he seems like he has his shit, together with having the scanner in his ear, finding a secluded place to put her, a secluded place to pick her up at. But then there's all these moving parts that just are like, oh, I'm out of gas. And like, oh, I need money.

Jess:

Like what you think. If you're going to go murder somebody, you would, you know, top off the gas tank or something. Just kidding.

Hannah:

But yeah, seriously, this is very strange, but this obviously isn't his first killing. No, he's starting to get sloppy.

Jess:

Yeah, and overconfident, I think.

Hannah:

Yeah.

Jess:

And it goes to show you, because how many times is that that they've been around people and he was able to, like, get her to comply?

Hannah:

Yeah.

Jess:

So he finally gets back to the house and trigger warning. He proceeds to sexually assault Samantha and then strangles her. He then heads into the house to pack for a pre-planned cruise that he and his girlfriend and his daughter are leaving for at 5 am.

Hannah:

Okay, we need to start actually videotaping us when we do this, because my faces are right in this episode are like cringe.

Jess:

Yes, your reactions I love. What the fuck yeah. So Dwayne was supposed to pick Samantha up that night from work and he had driven over to the kiosk and the lights were turned off and everything was locked up.

Hannah:

Wait a minute, wait a minute. He let her lock up, so you're saying he went to the kiosk. The lights were off and he let her lock up.

Jess:

Maybe no, actually, you know what I don't know about that? The lights were turned off and it seemed like everything was locked up.

Hannah:

Let's say that Okay, sorry, I didn't mean to call you out there, but that's okay. I was like really, yeah, just lock up, as usual, I'll wait right here. Mm-hmm.

Jess:

Freakin' weirdo he assumed that she had gotten a ride from a friend. But the next morning Dwayne and her father, james Samantha's father James realized that Samantha never came home and they hadn't heard from her, despite that text that she, in quotation, sent to Dwayne saying that she was going on vacation. But they knew that that was not like her, like something wasn't right. So James reports her missing, and James Koenig's relationship with the police wasn't necessarily a good one.

Jess:

Uh-oh, he felt like the police weren't taking his daughter's disappearance seriously and he was the one that was out coordinating searches and raising reward money for any information about Samantha, and he was able to raise $70,000. Wow, yeah. The next day, the police were able to get security footage from the kiosk and once they looked at it, they discovered that she wasn't a teen runaway and they stepped it up into high gear. The video showed Samantha getting robbed, tied up and taken from the kiosk, and they were able to discover the ATM transaction. Keys attempted to verify that the pin Samantha had given her. There was a video, but it was not helpful. Keys had hidden his identity and at this point there hadn't been any activity for days because he was enjoying life on a cruise Like a freaking cycle path.

Hannah:

Yeah, so it's better not be a Disney cruise, because I'm picturing him dancing with Minnie and Mickey and it's sickening.

Jess:

Ugh, it probably was. Meanwhile. Keys was back from his cruise around, I believe, the 17th and he had to do something about Samantha. So he had taken keep in mind he had taken Samantha on February 1st, left for his cruise on the 2nd and didn't come back until February 17th. So Samantha's body was in the shed for 15 days or 13 days, but it um two weeks.

Hannah:

This doesn't make it any better, but if it was Alaska in January at least it was cold and yeah.

Jess:

Yeah, and that's what I say now. And that's what I say next is that obviously in Alaska in February it's cold, so her body was kept cool. Yeah, and he actually warmed up the shed and decided to create the ransom note to see if he could get money. This fucking guy puts foundation on her body the parts are showing and then does her makeup, then tries to pose her with a paper from February 13th as proof of life for the ransom note. And do you want to know why he chose the paper from February 13th?

Hannah:

Do I want to know?

Jess:

Because it was when he was on the cruise, and so he figured it would be a way to clear him if he was ever suspected.

Hannah:

Ah, fucking douche.

Jess:

So Keyes attempts to pose her, but her face doesn't have any facial expression because she's dead. So he tries to super glue her eyes open, and that doesn't work. So this bastard takes a needle and thread and sews through her eyebrows and her eyelids to keep her eyes open, to make it look like she's still alive. And so there's this.

Hannah:

What.

Jess:

Yeah, like, what kind of fucked up bullshit is that? So he takes a picture and then copies it onto a piece of paper and then types up a ransom note requesting $30,000. And there is a picture online that when you Google Samantha's ransom note picture, there is a picture out there and a lot of sources say that is the picture. But the picture, the actual picture of Samantha has never been released. So whatever pictures out on the internet isn't her. Just so you know.

Hannah:

It's so. It just someone trying to.

Jess:

Yeah, it's like a recreation of that picture.

Hannah:

Have you seen it?

Jess:

Yeah, I've seen that one. Yeah, so her hair was braided and she had duct tape over her mouth. But isn't that one a mess up? One, yeah, yeah. So this wasn't until February 24th, three weeks since Samantha disappeared. Keys sends a text to Dwayne from Samantha's phone telling him that the ransom note has been left on the bulletin board on a trailhead at this random park. Police responded to that location and found the note with her proof of life picture on it, and the police were actually unsure if she was still alive in the picture, but it created a little bit of hope that she'd be found. The detectives convinced James to at least put $5,000 of the reward money that he had raised into her bank account. They wanted to entice whoever took her to use the ATM in order to track him down, and James agreed to transfer money into Samantha's account. So before we go further into Samantha's case, we want to take a break.

Hannah:

Break.

Jess:

A sincere expression of gratitude to our Steen patrons Lynn from Massachusetts, heather from New Jersey, courtney from Massachusetts, amber from Idaho and Chelsea from Utah For their generous monthly contributions. Their support fuels the engine of our investigative endeavors here at Wicked Wanderings.

Hannah:

You too can become a valued patron and unlock a realm of exclusive content by supporting our mission for as little as $3 a month. Your contribution sustains our commitment to delivering high quality content.

Jess:

Visit WickedWanderingsPodcastcom and click on the support tab to join the ranks of dedicated patrons like Lynn, heather, amber, courtney and Chelsea. Your investment not only keeps our podcast thriving, but also ensures you are at the forefront of intriguing discoveries.

Hannah:

Thank you for considering this opportunity to deepen your engagement with Wicked Wanderings. Your support is paramount in enabling us to continue our journey into the realms of mystery and true crime.

Jess:

And now back to the shit show. All right, so again, before we go into Samantha's case, let's get some background information on Israel. He was born January 7, 1978 in Richmond, utah, and, like I said, I didn't know that because I was trying to get away from Utah and he was the second of 10 kids, holy moly, yeah. And his parents held some fundamental and extremist beliefs, but he was born into the FLDS religion, really so, which is the fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and for all use, I'll use out there, some people confuse this with the LDS or the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints or what I make fun of as Mormons. But it's actually a break off of the LDS, and the FLDS continue to practice polygamy, among other things. So think Warren Jeff's cringey old men marrying 70, 14 year olds. So that's what he was born into Weirdos.

Hannah:

Not the Mormons, I mean, there's some.

Jess:

Warren Jeff's. Yeah, talk about cringy. The family then moved to a remote area in Colville, washington, when Keyes was five years old. They lived in a one room cabin. You know, two parents, 10 kids, all right, that fits, yeah. And they were isolated from society. They attended a church called the Ark, which practiced white supremacy ideology.

Hannah:

Oh God, this kid had no chance, Nope.

Jess:

They also attended a church called Christian Israel Covenant that taught British Israelism as doctrine and thought that mixed marriages were abominable and deviant. So they were not. Wow, they did not believe in mixed race relationships. They believe that the Anglo-Saxons were to rule over the perceived inferior races, which keys alleged to have been militia, like white supremacy. The children the keys children were made to hunt for food, chop firewood, firewood, firewood and work on local farms to support the family. I hate to laugh at this, but sometimes you just have to, because when I'm an idiot and to this is very serious you are not an idiot.

Hannah:

You're brilliant.

Jess:

Keep it going. Remind me to pay you later. As a hobby, keys recalled hunting anything with a heartbeat, he admitted, and trigger warning animal cruelty. He admitted to skinning a deer while it was alive to peers at church. He had shot the deer but it wasn't dead yet and he started to skin it while it was injured and still alive because of.

Hannah:

I'm sorry when it comes to animals. For some reason it's like you get so angry, Like you watch a horror story All these people getting killed and you're like, yeah, but is the puppy okay?

Jess:

Because that's the important part. I get so pissed I read, and maybe it's because they can't defend themselves.

Hannah:

I think that must be it it must be it. Yeah.

Jess:

Because of stuff like this, he was ostracized and actively avoided by other kids in the church.

Hannah:

Well, I can see why.

Jess:

He had a history of harming animals and fire setting and there was another incident in which keys was with some friends of the family and he took the family cat, tied it to a tree, shot it in the stomach and it flew around the tree like a tetherball. It crashed into the tree and vomited. He looked back to the kids he was with and one of the boys started vomiting as well and he states that at this point he realized he was different from his peers and he started to keep his growing anti-social behavior to himself and began to withdraw socially.

Hannah:

Okay, I am seeing like check, check, check, check on a mental health list here Like, oh yeah, yep, that this is rough, all right yeah.

Jess:

During his teenage years the family moved to Maine where he built his first wood cabin for his family at 16. So he became quite the carpenter. I was almost about to make a Jesus joke.

Hannah:

I would have been so wrong?

Jess:

Were you thinking the same thing?

Hannah:

I was just saying well, jesus was a carpenter, I that's yeah. Anyway, moving on Again. Sorry, mom.

Jess:

They lived in a mostly Amish community and during this time, keys renounced his Christian faith and declared his atheism to his parents, who then shunned him and kicked him out and told his siblings not to have any contact with him. He developed an interest in Satanism and had plans to commit a ritualistic murder, Because you know what else is there to do in Maine, I guess I don't know.

Hannah:

I mean, so I don't know if you know anything about the Church of Satan. I don't, but it's really not about worshiping Satan.

Jess:

Mm, hmm, I've heard that.

Hannah:

That's the thing, Like that's. What kind of. That's what I'm laughing at.

Jess:

Yeah, not the part that he's killing people, but okay, Anyways continue on the fact that he wants to commit a ritualistic murder. Yeah, so we see the history of behavior that leads up to becoming the serial killer. You know, checking off the list, yeah.

Hannah:

Well right, Because he's obviously in some type of mental distress.

Jess:

Yeah, he has a history of fire setting, killing animals, but he was also emotionally cast out by his father, who himself engaged in extremist religious practices.

Hannah:

But it doesn't sound like this kid ever went to public school Like you know they were home schooled, yeah, so it definitely couldn't have been caught by any type of social worker or teacher?

Jess:

No, and he also did a three year tour in the army from 1998 to 2001. Crazy huh, and he passed. Yeah, I said he did. He actually did really well in it.

Hannah:

Wow.

Jess:

And that was before the war, so he got out right, right right. But I think he was in Egypt. We'll get into that when we talk about other possible victims.

Hannah:

Huh.

Jess:

So now that we have that history, let's get back to his involvement with Samantha's disappearance. So after James Koenig deposited $5,000 into Samantha's account, there was a withdrawal in Anchorage, alaska. There is a video in this withdrawal and it seemed like he was testing the daily limit because he attempted a few times. Then, a few days later, there was another withdrawal, but this one was 4,000 miles away in Wilcox, arizona. Then another one in Lord'sburg, new Mexico, and then another one in Humboldt Texas, and then another one in Shepherd Texas.

Hannah:

Wait, they're, but they're not checking her bank account. No, they are.

Jess:

They're watching it. Oh, okay, yeah, so authorities realized that he is headed east across the I-10 corridor.

Hannah:

Okay, Sorry, I spoke to you too soon. Well, no, good question.

Jess:

So now they still don't know who they are dealing with. They have no idea. There was no evidence as to who this guy was and if he had known, Samantha Keys did make one mistake. However, at the ATM withdrawal in Arizona, despite Keys hiding his identity on video like he would wear a hat oops, a mask. Sorry, I just bumped the mic.

Hannah:

Sorry, I talked with my hands.

Jess:

Are you Italian? No, I'm not, not that I know of. Sorry, maybe I should do one of those DNA tests, but no, oh, you haven't done okay.

Hannah:

That's another podcast. Sorry, you're going, so he would wear a hat, a mask and glasses and gloves so you couldn't even tell what race he was in.

Jess:

Like that's the links that he went to hide his identity Race. He was in, race he was. Sorry, hannah made me do a shot before this episode, so I'm blaming her. Ready for another. What race he was, what ethnicity he was Hannah.

Jess:

Sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, what ethnicity he was, hannah. Sorry I sound so edumacated, god. Anyways, despite hiding his identity on video, there was a white Ford Focus in the background that he is seen getting into. Authorities put out a bolo to all law enforcement along the I-10. For the Ford, obviously for the Ford Focus. Just A Texas State Police officer finds the Ford Focus in the parking lot of a hotel along the highway.

Jess:

He calls it in and he is told to watch it to see who comes out and gets in the car. They don't have to wait long, as there is a tall man that leaves the hotel and gets into the car. The officer is instructed to follow him as he gets on the highway. They run the plates and find out that it is a rental. The officer is then instructed to find a reason to pull him over anything that gives him probable cause. Eventually the car goes above the speed limit just barely, but it's enough to legally pull him over. The officer pulls up behind the car and asks the driver for his license. And that is when they finally have a name Israel Keys from Alaska. Why is a man from Alaska driving a rental car through Arizona, new Mexico and Texas? Good question, you know who.

Hannah:

I'm worried about is the daughter.

Jess:

Yeah, so she is supposed to be. So Keys states that he's in Texas for a family wedding, which is true, and he is supposed to have his daughter. His daughter flew with him from Anchorage, Is she 10? You said yeah, but she's not with him. He says that she's with his brother when he gets pulled over.

Hannah:

So I know you said that he looked up to Ted Bundy. This is very Ted Bundy like, because we know that Ted Bundy had a relationship and she didn't know for ever what was going on. So that really reminded me of Ted Bundy with that part.

Jess:

And so his daughter's from a previous relationship, but even his girlfriend and he makes sure he's like she had no idea what was going on, and neither did his baby mama know what was going on? Yeah, and he, he and we'll get into this more in the next episode but he tells Detectives that he's like there's two sides of me and the only person that knows about this other side is me, so you don't need to talk to anybody else about it. Yeah, that's very easy.

Hannah:

Ted Bundy like as well.

Jess:

So they end up searching his car and finding Samantha's debit card and her cell phone and what seems like a kidnapping kit in the trunk. So keys is arrested and taken to the local police station and at this point in the investigation FBI is also involved, working with the local police departments. Keys is extradited back to Anchorage within a few days and the interviews begin, and you will never know what this douche canoe reveals. Oh, boy. But you'll have to wait till next week to find that out.

Hannah:

Oh, come on.

Jess:

So wait till next week. With that day, yep for the continuation of major douche canoe is real keys. We'll get into his confessions and his Victims and how he totally played the authorities that were involved, like he had total control over the interrogations.

Hannah:

I'm so sad. I'm like so ready, I Know, but it'll be next week. Thanks for a great episode. That was really good.

Jess:

It's crazy looking forward to the next one. Thanks, so have a wonderful Blessed day, wanderers.

Hannah:

Yes, bye, wanderers. Love, you mean it Bye. Thanks for listening today. The show wouldn't be possible without our amazing producer and editor, rob Fitzpatrick, who works tirelessly behind the scenes to bring you the best content.

Jess:

And a special thanks to Tyga sound prod for providing the captivating intro music, cinematic intro 24 and of course, we can't forget the hauntingly beautiful outro music, rhino scene, composed by Kevin McLeod if you enjoyed today's episode, make sure to leave a rating and review on our your favorite podcast Platforms like Spotify, apple and YouTube. Your feedback means the world to us.

Hannah:

Also be sure to follow us on Instagram for behind the scenes blimpses, updates and more thrilling content. You can find us at wicked wanderings podcast.

Jess:

Thank you so much for listening and being part of our wicked wanderings community. We appreciate each and every one of you.

Hannah:

Stay curious keep exploring and always remember to keep on wandering. You, you, you, you.

Serial Killer Israel Keyes
Keyes' Disturbing Actions and Miscalculations
Serial Killer Background and Investigation

Podcasts we love