Wicked Wanderings
Delve into the enigmatic realms of the mysterious, unearth tales of haunting encounters, explore the chilling depths of true crime, and unravel the threads of the unexplained. Join us on the Wicked Wanderings Podcast for a riveting journey through the realms of the unknown and the haunting mysteries that linger in the shadows.
Wicked Wanderings
Ep. 10: The Salem Witch Trials Part 3
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In the gripping finale of our three-part series on the Salem Witch Trials, Wicked Wanderings takes you on a journey into the aftermath of this harrowing chapter in history. Join us as we explore the fates of the accused, the lasting impact on Salem, and the enduring questions that haunt the legacy of the trials.
After the trials concluded and the hysteria subsided, what happened to those who were accused, convicted, or found innocent? We'll unravel the stories of the survivors, the wrongly accused, and those who paid the ultimate price.
But the Salem Witch Trials left more than just scars on the individuals involved. The repercussions extended to the town, its community, and the collective psyche of a nation. We'll examine the theories and explanations for why this dark episode unfolded, from religious fervor to political motivations and beyond.
As we close this chapter in the Salem Witch Trials saga, Wicked Wanderings invites you to reflect on the consequences and the enduring mysteries of this enigmatic and haunting period in American history. Subscribe now to join us in the final leg of this chilling journey through one of the darkest episodes in the annals of true crime and the unexplained.
If you'd like to show your support for Wicked Wanderings and join our community of dedicated listeners, you can start contributing for as little as $3 a month. Your support helps us continue to explore the darkest and most intriguing mysteries, bringing you captivating stories from the world of true crime and the unexplained. Click the link to become a valued member of our podcast family.
Don't forget to rate, review, and follow us on your favorite streaming platform.
Wicked Wanderings Website
Linktree
Instagram
We'd love to hear from you!
Email us @ wickedwanderingspodcast@gmail.com
Text Us @ CLICK HERE
Wicked Wanderings is hosted by Hannah & Courtney and it's produced by Rob Fitzpatrick. Music by Sascha Ende.
Wicked Wanderings is a Production of Studio 113
The Salem Witch Trials
Speaker 1What's your perfect day ? April 24th or something hot , not too cold . You just need a light jacket like sweater .
Speaker 2Hello wanderers , I'm Jess and I'm Hannah , and welcome to wicked wanderings . Hello Hannah , hello Jess . I just said Hannah . Really weird , sorry about that . How's it going ? It's ?
Speaker 1going . I'm here with you , so I'm happy . How are you ? Oh , oh .
Speaker 2Listen to you . We're crying over here at wicked wanderings . Are you ready to be finished with the Salem witch trials ?
Speaker 1It's been a long road but you have done has an amazing job . You could have wrote a thesis paper .
Speaker 2I could have done like a whole season , yeah , on each part of it pretty much , and I went down a rabbit hole . I was not prepared for that rabbit hole , are you Alice ? Yes , and so I've given you guys a lot of information and I've enjoyed it and it's been a lot . So that's what she said . So let's get started with our final episode of the Salem witch trials . We left off last week of the creation of the court of Euler and Terminer right , and then I gave you an extensive history of the first 30 or so people who had been accused in four months .
Speaker 2I can't possibly go through the 200-ish people that would eventually be accused of witchcraft . I want to only because I feel as though they should be acknowledged for the bullshit that they went through , and I also have a low key fear of being lost to history myself . But that is a conversation for me and my therapist . Yeah , the podcast . So for this final episode , I want to focus on those that were executed , and wrongfully in my opinion , and I think you all have gathered how biased I am and how ridiculous I think the trials are by now and , as we will see , it seems that after the trials ended , everyone else did too . It seems that Salem and Salem village wanted to move on from the embarrassment and the wrongs that were done . There are very little personal accounts from that time and a lot was destroyed in the aftermath . Didn't know if you knew that .
Speaker 1No , I didn't know . So they like got rid of stuff .
Speaker 2Yeah , a lot of the court Documents survived , but a lot of people who kept journals Didn't have anything for that year , which is they wrote every day , and so a few years missing , yeah , so I think people were wanting to forget . But I am glad that we have the trial transcripts , that we do . But let's continue . So I gave you a visual and you might need that now . Let me grab mine that .
Speaker 2I forgot where I put it and you're gonna , we're gonna add this to yes , I will add this and I will make more when this episode airs , so it should be on the Instagrams before we get into the trials . Let's talk about the justices of the court of Euler and Terminer . I've put the family tree , the connection between some of them , on our Instagram , so check that out . At Wicked Wanderings podcast there were nine in total and there were some changes along the way as well . The chief justice is William Stanton and the other magistrates are the OG pecker heads , john Hawthorne and Jonathan Corwin .
Speaker 2Then we have Samuel Sewell , bartholomew Gedney , john Richards , nathaniel Saltinsell , peter Sargent and Wastel Winthrop . So this is gonna get a little messy to explain . So , like I said , check out our Instagram and I've already given Hannah my copy , so let's see if I can do this . John Richards is Wait Winthrop's brother-in-law . John is married to wait sister and Winthrop waits other sister , margaret Winthrop married John Corwin , but don't confuse John Corwin with Jonathan Corwin . Jonathan Corwin is the magistrate and John Corwin is his brother , but he's not the magistrate confused yet .
Speaker 1I mean this is helping , okay , and I think you'll help our Wanderers too , because I'm such a visual person .
Speaker 2Yeah , it's like they only had five names to pick from back then , like Mary , martha , sarah , jonathan , thomas , william , william , yes , and a shit ton of .
Speaker 1Mary's yeah .
Speaker 2Fuckin Mary's . Okay , so basically , jonathan Corwin , the magistrate , is the brother of wait Winthrop's brother-in-law . Okay however , margaret Winthrop and John Corwin not the magistrate have a son named George Corwin Got it . George Corwin was the sheriff at the time and he was the one that was going around confiscating the accused properties .
Speaker 1Oh .
Speaker 2Okay , so George Corwin is the nephew of both magistrates wait , winthrop and Jonathan Corwin . George married Lydia Gedney , who happens to be the daughter of magistrate Balthaw Amu Gedney , now Magistrate . Jonathan Corwin has two sisters Actually has three , but we're just talking about two of them Elizabeth Corwin , who is married to Magistrate Peter Sargent , and Abigail Corwin , who is married to Eleazar Something or other Hawthorne , whose brother is John Hawthorne . So John Hawthorne is the in-law of Jonathan Corwin's sister . So basically what all of that says ? Incest ? Well , not quite , maybe , I don't know . So six of the nine justices are related somehow through blood and marriage . That's basically what that boils down to it looks like a clusterfuck to me .
Speaker 2Well , I mean , it fits with the times . All of Salem was a clusterfuck . All of these men were well read , widely traveled , men , of integrity and familiar with the workings of the court , but they didn't have any specific legal training . They represented the wealthy and the elite of the colony , and the shitty thing for the accused is that they didn't have any Representation and lawyers weren't really common in New England at the time , and this is before the Revolutionary War . So there is no Constitution or Bill of Rights and according to Emerson Baker in his book the storm of witchcraft , he says for a generation Magistrates had in fact been an important break on the general public's eagerness to prosecute witches , whom they feared and blamed for their misfortunes .
Speaker 2Most judges grew skeptical about Previously used ways of establishing that someone was a witch , and some even began to question the existence of witches . But for some reason , in 1692 , the Salem judges would reverse course . This is important . Their participation in the trials Shaped the outcomes , the conviction and the execution of 19 innocent people . No matter how many accusers suffered what they believed were genuine afflictions or conspired to press dubious charges , no one would have died without the sanction of the judges . It's all their fault . As a group . They represented the proverbial 1% , the merchant elite , who are wealthy , intermarried and exercise power in social , political and military circles . Some of the judges had been present for witch trials in the years leading up to Salem , which may have influenced their decisions here .
Speaker 2An Important thing to note is that the Salem witch trials heavily relied on spectral evidence . Spectral evidence is defined as acts carried out by the devil that only the accuser can see . The Puritans Generally believed that the devil could create such harmful specters . He tricked witches into believing that his powers were theirs . But how much weight should be given to the claim that a person was harmed by a spirit or specter of a person when only the Afflicted witnessed the manifestation ? So if only Anne Putnam could see people flying through the air , or why should we be paying attention to her ?
Speaker 1Because she's a putnam .
Speaker 2But at that time , to doubt a specter was to doubt God's existence , since such powers were ultimately derived by God , for he had created Satan . Before the trials even started , john Richards wrote to his minister , cotton Mather , for advice . Mather urged caution over the use of spectral evidence and believed that Richard should not lay more stress upon pure specter testimony Than it will there . So before the courts even started or the official trials even started , they were all questioning the use and reaching out to the ministers . Bridget Bishop was the first to be tried in the first session of the court of Euler and Terminer that began on June 2nd 1692 . The justices thought bishops case would be an easy one because it presented the strongest evidence for conviction . She had previously been charged with witchcraft and she had often been before the court . Both she and her second husband , thomas Oliver , had been convicted several times of domestic violence , one case taking place on the Sabbath . As a poor , coral some and Suspicious woman , bishop fit everyone's idea of a witch .
Speaker 2A total of 10 witnesses testified against her and her strange behavior Dating back to the 1670s , even though she was already acquitted from those charges in 1679 . Oh , so this is the second time ? Yeah , but I almost went off on a rant here because I was like hey , me being a crime junkie In my mind . If she was already acquitted of those charges in 1679 , how can they bring them back ? But also , that's looking at it through a 2023 lens and not a 1692 lens . The most damning evidence for Bridget came from John Bly and his son William , who had been hired by Bishop in 1685 to carry out some repairs on her home . When they went down to the cellar , they found holes between the stones in the wall with several poppets made of rags with headless pins in them , with the points outward . So this was considered voodoo .
Speaker 2So they were voodoo dolls it was basically what's considered voodoo dolls today . They did not provide the dolls as evidence , however , but this testimony would have been viewed as tangible proof of black magic , far more damning than spectral evidence . Now here is your favorite part , hannah . Can you guess what it is ? Witchcraft , well , yeah , but a panel of nine women and a surgeon , john Barton , examined Bishop for teats .
Speaker 2Oh boy , for our wonders out there who haven't listened to episode three or four , we explained teats are the devil's marks on a witch that their familiar will suckle on . Go , listen Episode three and four . Actually , just start at one and binge , please .
The Salem Witch Trials
Speaker 2After a diligent search , the group found an abnormal growth between her vagina and anus . That was not usual for a woman . That is how thorough these exams were . Bishop had a teat , but the messed up thing was she had to go through another examination several hours later and the teat had disappeared and was replaced by dry skin . What so ? She had nine people all up in her business looking for a teat between her vagina and anus , so they probably could have found something that was like cancerous on her , and yet she's going to die for witchcraft .
Speaker 1Yeah , rob , are you okay with the word ?
Speaker 2vagina .
Speaker 1Yeah , vagina is fine , with me Okay .
Speaker 2I'm just making sure every time I said it . You're kind of like vagina , yeah , so she had to go through a second examination , and by the time the jury began their deliberation , there was little doubt of outcome . Bridget was found guilty and sentenced to hang . On Friday , june 10th 1692 , sherwiff Corwin and his men led Bridget from the jail to common land at the outskirts of Salem town , to the place that would later be known as Gallows Hill , and Bridget was hanged by the neck until she was dead . Fucking Puritans .
Speaker 1Everything seemed to quiet down for a short period after Bridget's execution .
Speaker 2Only three people claimed to be afflicted by the specters and no new suspects were jailed . Some may have thought the worst was over , but they were not . On June 16th , roger Toothacre I think I mentioned him in the last episode died in the Boston .
Speaker 2Prison while awaiting trial . This would be the third death related to the trials . The first signs of opposition to the trials began to appear . Judge Nathaniel Saltinstall resigned from the court of Oyer and Terminer . He was the only one of the judges to be held accountable for the crime . He lived in Haverhill and not in Salem and it was widely known that he was very dissatisfied with the proceedings . Did I say it wrong ? Haverhill , haverhill , haverhill , worchester .
Speaker 1I'm going to get my .
Speaker 2Worchester Shire sauce . These Bostonians . I didn't hear anything else . You said I'm sorry , I'm sorry , I'm sorry , I'm sorry , I'm sorry , I'm sorry , I'm sorry , I'm sorry .
Speaker 1I didn't hear anything else you said except Haverhill .
Speaker 2Haverhill , haverhill , it's Haverhill . Yes , you know what I need to live here 12 years before I get that right .
Speaker 1I got Worchester right . I don't know if I can give you that much time .
Speaker 2Well , if the podcast continues , you're going to have to . Sorry , haverhill got me lost , so he lived in Haverhill and not Salem , and it was widely known , hannah , that he was very dissatisfied with the proceedings .
Speaker 1Thank you .
Speaker 2Let's wait until you try to pronounce Utah towns . Oh , I got this Challenge accepted . There would even be claims that his specter afflicted people . So he quit because he didn't agree with it , and then people were claiming that his specter was out and about . It's what ? Yeah ? So once he quit and wasn't satisfied with everything going on , then people started to accuse him . Oh brother , but and that's something that we begin to see with the people that speak out against the witch trials and he got off pretty well because he didn't get executed like some of the others .
Speaker 1So you have to be in cahoots if you don't agree with something .
Speaker 2Yeah , it's common . An interesting thing that I didn't know was that on June 13th Governor Phipps met with his council with four of the judges Stottin , sewell , winthrop and Sargent were present . According to Baker , the council asked a group of leading ministers of the colony for their opinion in the handling of the witchcraft proceedings . The ministers responded two days later . Their response was penned by Cotton Mather which , keep in mind , had already spoken to Richards about the same matter before the trials even started . The ministers showed support for the judge's difficult task , while they raised serious doubts about the use of spectral evidence . They were vague and encouraged the speedy and vigorous prosecutions . Ignoring or not fully understanding the minister's concerns about the spectral evidence , the judges interpreted this statement as a green light to continue with the prosecutions .
Speaker 2On June 25th , governor Phipps and his council received two petitions complaining about that use of spectral evidence . One was a Baptist minister who warned that several persons of good fame and unspotted reputation sat in jail solely upon specter testimonies and warned that a woeful chain of consequences will undoubtedly follow . But the overreliance on spectral evidence would also put everyone in the colony under the possibility of accusation , which wasn't received well by the governor as he , as the complainer was the Baptist for one . How dare he . But he was also the brother of a rebel in New York who was recently executed . Phipps summoned the minister before the council to explain his scandalous and seditious paper and required him to pay a 200 pound bond to prevent a repeat of such an outburst . The Puritans were not open to receiving any criticism to their work on the trials .
Speaker 1Of course not .
Speaker 2Men in their penises . The court reconvened on June 28th . I'm glad my mom doesn't listen , maybe she will and maybe she'll like it . Who would you say , jessica ? She would , oh , grabbing my pearls . I do declare the court reconvened on June 28th , with five women facing the court and all would be convicted of witchcraft . Sarah Good was the first name on the docket . Several of the afflicted girls testified of her specter attacking them . What are you laughing about over there ? There's specter attacking . I'm sorry .
Speaker 2No , it's ridiculous . What was worse was that many of the confessed witches , including Tituba , had named good in their confessions , saying she flew on a broomstick and had animal familiars and attended witch gatherings . One thing I remember reading or hearing and I think it may have been from unobscured season one with Erin Mankey we love you , erin is that oftentimes when one of the women confessed they would name another person who had already been named . They wouldn't accuse anyone else that the justices didn't already know about . But this evidence , on top of the spectral evidence , was enough for the jury to convict . Susanna Martin , the elderly Amesbury widow , was also tried that day and Cotton Mather would call her one of the most impudent , wicked creatures in the world and she would be convicted insense to death .
Speaker 2Next the court would call Rebecca Nurse . Her case would be much more difficult for the court . The 71-year-old was not a social outcast like Good and Bishop and she was actually a highly respected member of the Salem town . Rebecca's family had been actively working in her defense and they solicited testimony that questioned the raracity of Rebecca's accusers . They submitted a petition that was signed by 39 friends and neighbors in support of her innocence . Of course the prosecution supplied the testimony of spectral evidence from the afflicted girls , but also produced evidence that a panel of women and the surgeon , john Barton I bet he loved his job found that what they believed was a witch's teat . When they inspected Rebecca they didn't say where it was , so it wasn't between her vagina and anus apparently .
Speaker 1I do feel bad for that person , though Right , because it could have been something really medically serious yeah .
Speaker 2Or like a skin tag or something , or a mole , right , right . The jury returned initially . This part really pisses me off and it will probably piss you off too . The jury returned initially with a verdict of not guilty . The courtroom erupted with the not guilty verdict and the afflicted girls cried out and several of the judges seemed displeased . Obviously , this is what really makes me angry . Douche Canoe Stottin asked the jury to reconsider .
Speaker 2The jury deliberated further but uncertainty remained . So the foreman came back and asked Rebecca a question . She remained silent An action that was taken by the jury is guilt and finally returned with a guilty plea . The nurse's family complained that Rebecca was nearly deaf and did not hear the question . The foreman of the jury acknowledged that her silence was the principal evidence of her guilt . Despite this obvious miscarriage of justice , the conviction remained . Governor Phipps even granted a reprieve for Rebecca Nurse but then rescinded it due to the complaints by the afflicted and pressure from an unnamed Salem gentleman . I wonder who that was , bitches ? So five days later her fellow Puritan saints , to pour salt in the wound , formally turned their backs on her In her presence . The Salem Town Church members unanimously voted to excommunicate her .
Speaker 1Oh , for heaven's sakes .
Speaker 2Right . One more reason for me to hate the Puritans . What a bunch of jerks .
Speaker 1That's something that wouldn't Please . You would hope what had happened now , yeah .
Speaker 2I mean wait until we talk about Mormons and religious trauma . Just kidding for all you Mormon listeners . I love you .
Speaker 1Everyone's experience is different .
Speaker 2So we're taking a short break before I get back into the shit show that . I don't know if you guys know that when we start a podcast we have like host program when we have to sign up and then it releases the podcast to all the other , you know , to Apple , to Spotify , yada , yada .
Speaker 1Yeah , so you guys know this isn't free , like we spend money to do this because we enjoy doing it , but between the platform , the equipment , the materials , and it adds up , yeah .
Speaker 2However , I just want to shout out that we have listeners every week from Ireland oh , slange of us . So , hello Ireland . And we also have a listener from the UK Hello , united Kingdom . Right , and I've been watching , and don't get mad if I don't name your town so it gives us the information , the stats of downloads for our podcast . So I always see someone from Lansing , michigan , hey , miss , good , hello , lansing . And let me pull up the website real quick . On your episodes , you always get someone from Japan , japan , if you're listening , I have episodes to listen to mine . We have Lansing Michigan . That always shows up . Ooh , in the Netherlands , we see you , hello Netherlands . Of course , springfield , massachusetts . We get a lot of listeners from Ashland , massachusetts , oh , ashland , yeah , where's that , I don't know . Massachusetts , somewhere . Oh , and , of course , all of my People in Utah , whoop-boop , let's see what were some other ones . Indiana oh , hello Indiana . We've got Vermont , new Hampshire . Iowa I think Cresco , iowa Always listens , hello , iowa .
Speaker 1You know , I feel very honored to have listeners in Indiana , because is it crime ? Junkies established in Indiana ? Yes , yes .
Speaker 2I didn't even think about that . Oh , we love crime junkies . Arizona , which might be my brother , but oh , oh , hey , arizona , houston . Texas , so Jess you made that map right . I did , and it's all color coordinated and everything .
Speaker 1Yes , you should scan it in and put it on the Instagram .
Speaker 2I should , but I also have a challenge to those who listen to us . Oh , we have a Charleston , south Carolina . Oh yes , lancaster , new York , and you meet Mississippi . So I have a challenge and I'm gonna put this map on our Instagram . And we are missing Pretty much the middle of the country . We're missing Wyoming , we're missing Kansas , nebraska , south Dakota , nebraska . So if you are able to get someone in that state to listen to us and proof that you do tag us in Wicked wanderings podcast on Instagram or whatever , then I'll do a little surprise for you .
Speaker 1Oh , I like surprise . I don't even know what the surprise is , so that's exciting Me neither .
Speaker 2But no , you'll be getting a surprise . It will be cool . So we just want to get more listeners . We want to reach all 50 states , dammit .
Speaker 1Yes , we do so , and I , but I am very proud of our international listeners right so like that's awesome .
Speaker 2Oh my gosh , can we be pen pals ? I land UK , netherlands .
Speaker 1New Zealand , south Africa was on there too .
Speaker 2Yes , yeah , south Korea , canada . So you guys are awesome . We love all of you we appreciate all of you . You're gonna make me cry , so we need to get back to the witchcraft .
Speaker 1Can we also I don't know when you want to mention it , but can we talk about the article too ?
Speaker 2Oh yes , go ahead , because you sent it to me and I need a drink of my hot cocoa that you've most lovingly made me .
Salem Witch Accusations and Land Disputes
Speaker 1So something interesting in our local news here in Western Massachusetts there was an article put out about ancestors , and fellow Wiccans in Salem have asked the state to Take the accused that died , unfortunately , to be acquitted , and they're basically put their names back in good standing .
Speaker 2So I thought that was amazing and what is awesome is because when I saw the article that you sent me , I was thinking it was the rest of the Salem witch trials , which I'm pretty sure they've already all been cleared , but no , this . They mentioned Margaret Jones , which we talked about in our first episode , because she was the first woman in Massachusetts to be tried and executed for witchcraft , and then goodie Glover , who I believe she was the one we talked about her , but it's been like years , it seems the good-win children . So that is awesome , that yes .
Speaker 1I thought I was even that long after . Yeah .
Speaker 2See , puritans , you should be more like the Wiccans . Just saying , the dynamic in Salem now changed . Previously , the women accused of witchcraft were poor , marginal members of society , but Rebecca nurse wasn't one of those . The religious , economic and political standing would normally have protected her . Her conviction Demonstrated that almost no one in the colony was safe .
Speaker 2The court session continued with Elizabeth Howe and Sarah Wilds . Both were top-spilled women who had been previously accused of witchcraft and and a lot of the evidence in these trials were from earlier periods as well , rather than the events that happened in Salem Village , though both faced spectral evidence from the afflicted . On July 19th 1692 , elizabeth Howe , sarah Wilds , rebecca nurse and Sarah Good were carted off to Gallows Hill to be executed Apparently . Salem Towns junior minister Nicholas noise asked Sarah Good one last chance to confess that she was a witch , so that she would not die . A liar what a douche . To which she replied you are a liar . I am no more a witch than you are a wizard , and if you will take away my life , god will give you blood to drink .
Speaker 1Oh .
Speaker 2After Sarah's final words , the executions took place without further incident , though people remembered Good's curse years later , when noise suffered an internal hemorrhage , leaving him to die choking on his own blood . Carmo's a bitch Shift notes that none of these women were part of Paris's congregation . Sarah Good's husband quickly agreed that she was a witch jackass . While France is nervous , right , she knew how to make .
Speaker 1Sorry , but she probably didn't give him some the other night .
Speaker 2I don't know Fuck you . I had a funny comment , but now it's gone , so we'll continue . Jessica , oh , I was gonna say she knew how to pick him , but now it's not that funny , while Francis nurse devoted whole days to prove .
Speaker 2To prove that Rebecca was not safe . For Rebecca , all had been in court before , which left them vulnerable . There was another way to make sense of the procession up the hill . It may not have been as evident back then as it is today , but 53 years before the trials , a sloppy Massachusetts clerk had drawn topsfields boundary over that of Salem Village . As a result , a portion of Southwest topsfield Was , by some reckoning's , a portion of northern Salem . A pitch battle ensued , largely on account of the precious resource Already in short supply . A pitch battle ensued largely on account of the precious resource already in short supply Wood . What they ran out of , wood , timber , oh , Sorry , I Know we both work today .
Speaker 1My brain is just blue . It's okay , it's like spaghetti at least you made money .
Speaker 2I worked for free .
Speaker 1That's what happens . You're in a master's program , that's true .
Speaker 2A long-standing feud divided the Putnam's of Salem and the towns of topsfield . The towns was a last name . A family , the Putnam's went to court again and again over this land . The courts ruled four times in favor of the towns . And and guess who had the maiden name of town and was from topsfield Putnam , rebecca nurse , oh oh yes , sarah Cloyce and Mary Estie , because they were all sisters . The house in the Estes were close . Elizabeth Howe and Rebecca nurse were sisters-in-law and Sarah Wilde's husband had helped establish the contested boundary .
Speaker 2There was not a single word mentioned of that land dispute during the trials and half of the witch accusations filed before July had been Thomas Putnam's . Anne Putnam had accused each of these women Rebecca Nair , sarah Cloyce and Mary Estie . All had the main name of town . They were in a dispute with the Putnam's overland , so Anne Putnam had accused each of these women . Putnam filed his last complaint on July 1st . Paris' niece Abigail also disappeared from the scene at this time . Something had clearly been resolved and it just happened to be a different matter than what the judges had in mind . After these executions , the accusations move from Salem to Andover while these trials are still going on in Salem . Side note , hannah , we need to make a trip to Andover , because the country's oldest remaining bookstore is in Andover , massachusetts .
Speaker 1Ooh , I love the bookstore Right .
Speaker 2And I see it as our duty to go check it out . I'm down . Okay , I love a good trip . Right , and a good bookstore . Okay , back to the shit show . The third session of the Court of Oyer and Terminer Sounds like a law school . Like not a law school , or Jonathan's Furniture Store . That's what he said . It starts the first week of August and with the trial and execution of George Burroughs , george Jacobs , john Proctor , john Willard and Martha Carrier . There are no widows , folk healers or beggars , but there was a man that petitioned the authorities for a change of venue , who was John Proctor , john Willard , who evaded arrest for a brief period , and George Jacobs , who claimed he was as much of a buzzard as a wizard .
Speaker 1Is it John Jacob Piper Smith Right ?
Speaker 2Juan Paco Pedro de la Mar Stottin began . That's the Spanish version . I learned it in high school .
Speaker 1I'm sorry , it feels like a Utah thing there's a lot of Utah things .
Speaker 2Stottin began on August 3rd with a case .
Speaker 1Tell us how for footsies again .
Speaker 2Oh that's cute . I love that you left that in . It was adorable , play footsie . Sorry , I didn't even notice . This time you were the one that brought it to my attention , but it's cute . Young love , not that young . Can you guys stop flirting , and can we ? Get back to the podcast , please . Stottin began on August .
Speaker 1I had to earn my dollar , that's true .
Speaker 2Stottin began on August 3rd with a case against Martha Carrier , who was accused on May 28th . She was apparently the caustic queen of hell , and word on the street was that Martha was a woman so guilty your mama's so fat Martha's so guilty that she had been a witch two years before she was born . I can't make this shit up . No , I don't need to , because it's so ridiculous . Martha appeared before a large crowd . The evidence had piled up steadily since her May hearing . Her sister and two of her children had confessed to attending satanic meetings with her and stated that she should be the queen of hell . Carrier hailed from a hotheaded family whose reputation she upheld . Susanna Sheldon showed up again to testify against her and , of course , thomas fucking Potnam cribe the tortures that his daughters received at the hand of Martha . The afflicted girls did their usual dramatic flailing and Hawthorne asked Martha if she saw the ghost that the girls were referring to , and Martha replied if I speak you won't believe me . The afflicted became worse and the girls flailing became so severe that their lives were in peril . Whatever that means , hawthorne ordered that Martha be tied hand and foot and carted away .
Speaker 2Martha was found guilty and sentenced to hang .
The Salem Witch Trials
Speaker 2John Proctor and his wife , elizabeth , were both found guilty , largely thanks to the testimony of their servant , mary Warren , and despite the two petitions in their support , with a total of 51 signatures attesting to their good character . In June , john Proctor had physically been physically examined by seven men in search for a teat , but nothing suspicious was found . I wonder if they examined his taint for his teat . Although there was plenty of spectral evidence against John Proctor , his own words and actions often came back to haunt him . Witnesses testified that Proctor threatened or admitted to beating several involved in the witch trials . Witnesses John and Elizabeth were sentenced to death , although Elizabeth's sentence was pushed back as she informed them that she was pregnant .
Speaker 2George Jacob Jean Glymish Tam Uanna was accused by his servant , sarah Churchill , along with others , including his granddaughter Margaret Jacobs , and although John Willilord didn't have a servant , his in-laws were more than willing to testify against him . They accused him of killing his nephew with black magic . Jacobs , going back to Jacobs , continued to declare his innocence and he was physically examined for signs that he was a witch . There was a suspicious mark found on his shoulder that was considered a teat . It was about a quarter inch long , with a sharp pointing drooping downwards on his shoulder . It was said that they ran a pin through it and it did not bleed . Witchcraft Jacobs was found guilty and sentenced to death . An interesting story about George Jacobs , or rather his body , is that after he was executed he was buried at Gallows Hill . His family retrieved his body and buried it on their farm . A skeleton was exhumed and then reburied on the farm in the mid-19th century , and it was believed to be Jacobs . The skeleton was then rediscovered by a bulldozer when the property was developed in the 1950s , safeguarded by Danver officials . The skeleton was quietly reburied on the Rebecca Nurse Farm , complete with the replica 17th century coffin and gravestone in 1992 .
Speaker 2So obviously my notes were a little messed up , so we're going back to John Willard . He was actually the deputy constable at the time of the witch trials . He was one of the first people to speak out against them and he had helped arrest the accused witches and soon began to doubt that so many could be guilty and he quit his job in protest . Shortly after big surprise , he was accused of witchcraft by Big surprise , and put him . He was accused a second time by his wife's grandfather , bray Wilkins , when he fell ill after receiving a cross look from Willard . Willard had fled once he was named and after he was examined the magistrates made it clear that they believed the fact that he'd fled was a sign of guilt . He was also charged with spousal abuse by family and neighbors who reported . He abused his wife and Beter often , but he denied those charges , saying that they were all lies . He asked his wife to testify but she was never questioned and he was convicted and sentenced to hang .
Speaker 2It appears the magistrates saved the best for the last session the king of hell himself , reverend George Burroughs . A large crowd gathered for the event , including the colony's most prominent divine , increase , mather In prominent divine . As Burroughs was a minister , they considered him the ringleader of the witches and this is one of my the Mathers , annoys me moments , as Cotton Mather stated that Burroughs had the promise of being a king in Satan's kingdom now going to be erected . So it was Cotton Mather who said that Burroughs was the king of hell . Hear the promise of being a king , and Satan's kingdom Repent and thou shalt be saved" . Anyway , okay , I'm done .
Speaker 2The court knew that in order to convict a minister they needed overwhelming evidence . They had roughly 30 witnesses to testify against boroughs . They testified against the evil actions of his specter and his superhuman feats of strength . Eight confess witches described him as being the head actor of their hellish rendezvous . I wonder who put them up to that . The torments had to be high drama and when they attempted to testify against him they began choking . Boroughs denials did not impress the court and he was found guilty in sentence to hang . An interesting note that I found on the history of Massachusettsorg website is that , according to handwriting analysis by Professor Peter Grund of the University of Kansas , the afflicted girls' testimonies were all written by Thomas Putnam and coincidentally , thomas Putnam also testified in the trial and used similar language to what was written in the girls' testimony .
Speaker 2Oh that sounds sneaky Shady . Two weeks later , boroughs , george Jacobs , john Proctor , john Willard and Martha Carrier were carted up to Gallows Hill for their execution . The crowd that gathered was a bit unsettled , as four men who had previously been regarded as solid members of the community were to be executed . When boroughs climbed the ladder , he made a compelling speech to express his innocence , complete with the perfect reciting of the Lord's Prayer . A feat believed impossible for a witch , but apparently he could do it .
Speaker 1You know , I know the Lord's Prayer and I would still be nervous in front of a group of people .
Speaker 2Let's hear it right now . I'm just kidding , you don't have to .
Speaker 1See , put me in the spot . I was like , uh , right .
Speaker 2Point proven . After the executions , due to the extreme heat at the time , the bodies had been buried immediately and , according to historians , the bodies were hastily thrown into a shallow grave , leaving boroughs' chin and hand , and someone else's foot , exposed . Ugh , you know what I fucked up . That's so messed up . Regardless of how they were buried , some of the dead did not lie long . John Proctor and George Jacobs' families came back after nightfall and removed the bodies of the loved ones and secretly reburied them near their homes . A similar tradition in the nurse family suggests that that family member removed her body as well and buried it in their family cemetery .
Speaker 2Accusations continued , but concern for the trials increased , specifically around the use of , once again , spectral evidence . Major Roger Pike , salisbury did I say that right , salisbury ? Salisbury Magistrate , wrote to express his concerns to Jonathan Corwin about spectral evidence and stated that he was worried that such a controversial evidence was given too much weight in the trials . He suggested that the court should ultimately let guilty live until further discovery than to put an innocent person to death . At least someone in Salem has a brain , or Salisbury , rather . Despite these concerns , the court of Euler and Terminer began another session on September 6th . They heard six more cases against Mary Bradbury , martha Corey , mary Estee , alice Parker and Ann Pewdiator . I don't really know what it's P-U-D-E-A-T-O-R Potato .
Speaker 2You know what ? That's what it is Potato and Dorcas Hor , all of which were found guilty in sentence to hang . Mary Bradbury was a well-respected woman of high social rank , the wife of Captain Thomas Bradbury and a leading citizen of Salisbury . At her trial , she came with a petition signed by 118 friends and neighbors attesting to her religious devotion and good character . Mary eventually received a temporary reprieve . Her supporters organized her escape from jail and put her into hiding . Mary Estee , on the other hand , her own niece , testified against her , and remember that Mary had already been released from prison but was re-arrested 48 hours later because of Mercy Lewis . Even the prisonkeepers defended the mother of seven , a model prisoner , unfailingly civil and sober . Estee submitted a petition to the bench . The court had allowed them neither counsel nor privilege of pleading their cases . She requested a fair and equal hearing of what may be said for them as against them . So it appears to me that whoever tries to fight it will eventually be executed . We see that with John Proctor , burroughs , nurse and now Mary Estee , english law guaranteed those rights , but Sutton still sentenced Mary to hang , and I have a feeling that Rob wants to take a break , and I have a feeling that Rob wants to take a break . Thank you to Lynn in Springfield and if you love our podcast and want us to keep doing it , you can make a monthly donation as little as three doll hairs at our Wicked Wandering Podcastcom to support all the work that we put in to give you guys a good time . So Wicked Wandering's podcastcom .
Witch Trials and Aftermath
Speaker 2In mid-September Paris , along with Nathaniel Putnam , visited Martha Corey in prison . Corey greeted them coolly and without the eagerness which she had received them Six months earlier . Paris found her to be unmoved and justified herself and condemned all that had done anything to her . Just discovery and condemnation . Those were Paris words , her just discovery . What a jerk . He suggested they pray . Can you imagine ? Martha had no interest . Paris and Nathaniel Putnam prayed and then announced the dreadful sentence of excommunication against his embittered parishioner . So can you imagine being in jail Like what did Paris expect for Martha to be all accepting and forgiving ? I would be mad as hell if I spent the last six months in a shitty jail just to be sentenced to death , and then the man who's partly responsible wants me to pray with him .
Speaker 1Fuck you , Paris , Right right .
Speaker 2Seriously , these people have lost their minds .
Speaker 1And you know what the amazing thing is is probably God's shaking his head Right . If , anyways , dude was wrong with you .
Speaker 2I wonder if Martha Corey visited him in hell , because I think she went to heaven and he didn't . Alice Parker was the wife of a fisherman , John Parker . The couple lived in Salem town and Alice was a pious , honest woman . But she also had a reputation for clairvoyance and on one occasion had successfully predicted that a friend's husband would die at sea . She was accused by Mary Warren and in May , who claimed Parker had bewitched her mother to death and made her sister ill . Ann Padeir was a 70 year old widow in Salem town where she worked as a nurse and midwife . She had a reputation for being sharp tongued and often quarreled with locals . She was accused by many of the afflicted girls in . Some of her medical supplies and ointments were confiscated and introduced as objects of the occult .
Speaker 2Trying to keep up with the mounting accusations , the court heard nine more cases the next week and produced nine more convictions Big surprise . And these ones are ones I haven't really heard . I think most of the well known witches are from like the beginnings . So Abigail Faulkner , Margaret Scott , Wilmot Redd and Mary Parker were tried , found guilty and sentenced to hang the other five and foster her daughter , Marcy Lacey . Mary Lacey , not Marcy . Samuel Wardwell , Rebecca Eames and Abigail Hobbs had pled guilty at arraignment . When Samuel Ward Wardwell , when his confession was read to him , he recanted and changed his plea to not guilty . He was quickly tried , convicted and sentenced to death . Out of these nine , only four Mary Parker , Wilmot Redd , Margaret Scott and Samuel Wardell made it to the gallows , and one and foster would eventually die in prison in December 1692 .
Speaker 2The court adjourned on September 17th and was not supposed to resume until November . However , there was still something they had to do about Giles Corey . Giles had pled not guilty , but he refused to answer the next question Would you be willing to be tried by God and country ? In the absence of his answer , technically they could not proceed . So the court undertook the very traditional but rarely used strong and hard punishment .
Speaker 2They laid Giles down in the meadow between boards and placed progressively more rocks on top of the planks to literally press an answer out of him . He still refused to reply to the question . As they piled on rocks , Word has it that Corey's last words were more weight when they asked him to respond . According to Baker , this seems in keeping with what was known of the stubborn and quarrelsome old man who demonstrated such contempt for the court and the weight finally crushed him to death . Corey had seen the fate of others brought before the court and he believed his trial would end with his execution . So Corey rather chose to undergo what death they would put to him . The day before his death the Salem Town Church excommunicated Giles , and personally I think he was better off not being a member of that church anyway .
Speaker 1Did him a favor .
Speaker 2Yeah . Three days later , on September 22nd 1692 , martha Corey , margaret Scott , mary Estee , alice Parker and Anne Bodator I'm sorry , this is not disrespectful to you , anne , it's just funny . I'm sorry I'm messing up your name Wilmot Redd , samuel Wardell and Mary Parker were excommunicated , executed . The executions gave voice to a growing opposition to the trials . Many of the observers were taken aback by the treatment of Giles Corey and no one who actually confessed to being a witch had been executed , with the exception of Samuel Wardell , who recanted his confession . However , the outbreak continued to spread Increase . Martha soon took a series of actions to bring a halt to the trials . About fucking time , martha . He presented a manuscript Cases of Conscience to Governor Phipps . October would find the end of the witch trials , but not for the reason you would think , like you know the death of 19 innocent people . But no .
Speaker 2On October 12th 1692 , governor Phipps wrote to the Secretary of Privy Council and this was the first time that Phipps had reported on the witch trials to his superiors in England and told them he was forbidding any more charges of witchcraft except under extreme circumstances . Phipps noted in his letter I have found that the devil has taken upon him the name and shape of several persons who are doubtless innocent and , to my certain knowledge , of good reputation . But what Phipps didn't mention was that one of the victims recently named was his wife . Oh , so convenient , lady Mary Phipps . Isn't that just one of the biggest how convenience of the whole story ? For reals ? Phipps also banned the publications on the subject . The court of Euler and Terminer was officially disbanded and there was a creation of a general court that did not accept spectral evidence as evidence . It only took what ? Six months , seven months ? Stanton's work came to a sudden halt . And what are you laughing at ?
Speaker 1I just myself . I apologize and it's having problems . I really am . I'm sorry , it was a long day . I apologize , it's okay it's okay .
Speaker 2Stanton's work came to a sudden halt and the return to normal took a little longer . Economically and emotionally , Orchards , cellars , fences and woodpiles had been sacrificed in the name of justice . There was cause for much soul searching at the Salem Village Parsonage , as anywhere . Five accusers and four of the afflicted lived at that address . More than any other , Paris was not insensitive to the burdens his family had placed on the community . He offered to forgo six pounds of his 1692 salary to gratify neighbors . In an attempt to gain harmony , he made no move to retrieve tituba an embarrassment and an expense . She remained behind bars until someone paid her jail costs at the end of 1693 , effectively buying her , and she left Massachusetts , and this is the saddest part of all . At the time of her release , little Dorothy Goode had spent eight and a half months in jail . Her infant sister died before her eyes and she had watched her mother , against whom she had testified , head off to the gallows . Dorothy would eventually go insane and would require care for the rest of her life .
Speaker 1Oh .
Speaker 2Isn't that nice Shift goes into more of the details about the aftermath of the trials . So please , if you are interested , and I'll check out her book the Witches it's very informative . And one thing that's kind of like karma is that Thomas and Anne Sr Putnam died like within two years of the trials , and Anne Putnam , 19 , had to take care of or Anne had to take care of seven children , holy moly , and she died at 19 years old , I think . Oh , my goodness , yeah , single and destitute . But she was also the only one to apologize . Wow , sorry , my parents put me up to it , just kidding . So , before we end this long episode , we wanna talk about the theories that I so unbiasedly talked about during the episode Go for it and some that I have not mentioned .
Poisoning and Witch Trials in Salem
Speaker 2So there's Aragot poisoning , which I personally don't believe is a thing .
Speaker 1Now , could you explain what Aragot is ?
Speaker 2Aragot is . Let me check my notes , isn't it ? This doesn't say what it is . I just assumed everybody , but it's a grain , I think , mold . Anyway , look up Aragot . But many historians believe that they got an Aragot infestation in Massachusetts that caused strange activities among the women in 1691 that eventually led to the Salem witch hunts . Toxicologists now know that Aragot poisoning can lead to convulsions , spasms , hallucinations , crawling sensations on the skin and erratic behavior .
Speaker 1So I looked up Aragot poisoning . Thank you , and it is when a person or animal eats food that has been contaminated with a fungus called C perpuria . Oh well , there you go wonders . And like you said , it can cause gangrene , vision problems , confusion , spasms , convulsions , unconsciousness and death . Dun dun dun .
Speaker 2Also , I think the fucking Puttnums had a lot to do with it , but the land disputes that's what I have on my notes , fucking Puttnums and I think that they just took personally . I think that they just took advantage of an already crazy situation and once they had accomplished what they were set out to like , they kind of disappeared from the scene and then it moved to Andover . There were new people accusing and different people that were being charged . Another thing that I think played an important role was hysteria Now hysteria . Everything that's been going on in Salem , in the colony , the Wabanaki attacks in Maine , the charters being withdrawn . They were in between those charters at that time and some of the laws they stuck to and some of the laws they didn't . It seemed like they were picking and choosing which ones they wanted to follow . So another thing a recent epidemic of smallpox , the heightened threats of the Indian tech , the economic uncertainties and small town rivalries may have all primed the people of Salem and its surrounding areas for the mass hysteria that fueled the witchcraft rise .
Speaker 1So basically , it was a perfect storm .
Speaker 2Yes , but my favorite theory because you know I'm in the mental health field is conversion disorder .
Speaker 2Ooh , do tell have you ever heard of that ? Conversion disorder is a psychiatric disorder characterized by signs and symptoms affecting sensory or motor function inconsistent with patterns of known neurologic diseases or other medical conditions and significantly impact the patient's ability to function . The symptoms cannot be controlled at will not considered to be feigned intentionally by the patient . The term conversion disorder was first mentioned in literature by Sigmund Freud . Oh Freud , it must have been their mothers , yeah me . Psycho-psychological , social and biological factors can contribute , precipitate and perpetuate conversion disorder . Often there is trauma which is present , adverse life events a ton of it and acute chronic stressor preceding symptoms of conversion disorder .
Speaker 2Many patients are found to have a history of childhood abuse , both emotional and sexual . Contributing to conversion disorder include poor coping skills and internal psychological conflicts . They are more likely to have a history of multiple somatic complaints , including symptoms like generalized fatigue , weakness or pain without a known cause . So there's a bunch of like models that it aligns with , so I'm just going to read a couple of things and then we'll be done . The psychodynamic models suggest that somatic symptoms of conversion disorder are a product of emotional conflict . This emotional conflict becomes repressed into the unconscious mind and converted into a symptom .
Speaker 2Some other models focus on the development of inadequate coping mechanisms and negative interpersonal relationships that develop early in a patient's life . And then cognitive behavioral models suggest that exposure to information related to a specific symptom can lead to the creation of representation in memory . Conversion order then occurs when this representation is activated by an individual worrying excessively about looking for signs of that symptom . This activation passes a specific threshold in the mind where it overrides sensory input and becomes an actual symptom . And these symptoms would explain , like the rigid body movements in the beginning , where it looks like they're going through an exorcist where their bodies are all Exorcism , yeah , yeah .
Speaker 1So the last part you were saying was that kind of when you have people that can be hypochondriacs and be like , oh , I'm getting a sniffle , see , I have my sniffle , and you start getting in your head that you're going to be sick , and then you get sick .
Speaker 2Well , and this could also explain while both Abigail and Betty started fits at the same time , because maybe one started first and then the other one followed after . I get this when I hate throwing up , hate it and when I know I've been around somebody with a stomach bug then my stomach starts to feel like am I getting sick ?
Speaker 2Yeah , am I going to puke , but that's on a lesser level . So that , for me , I think , is the most reasonable one to explain all the weird behavior . That was not faked . I think some of it was fake , looking at you , ann Putnam , but I think that , like you said , the Salem witch trials were just a perfect storm of years of stress , of economic stress , of the fear of the Native American attacks , and I think it just plus the testosterone of the judges .
Speaker 1Yeah , absolutely . And also , like you had talked about the no charters and everything , this was getting to a point where I'm sure they felt they were separating from England a lot and , like you said , it's not near the revolutionary , as close to the Revolutionary War . But they probably started like , well , we're kind of on our own , like , yeah , the king can send over whatever he wants .
Speaker 2But we're on our own over here , yeah , and I mean , it takes months for anything to get back and forth .
Speaker 1I do want to give a huge shout out to you , though . This was a lot . This was five episodes and you did a lot of work , so clap for me .
Speaker 2I can think about other things .
Speaker 1Sorry if there's a little much . I really think you should get a doctorate just because of all the work you did on this .
Speaker 2I could have done , like I said , a whole season , maybe someday , because I still want to read thoroughly some of the books I had .
Speaker 1Absolutely . I think we can totally do something .
Speaker 2Maybe not . No , maybe in two years .
Speaker 1I need a break . You deserve that break .
Speaker 2Yes , but there we go . I hope you enjoyed and I hope I wasn't thoroughly you know what . I'm OK being thoroughly biased about how it went down , because it was bullshit .
Speaker 1Well , I think that's what's great about a podcast we can say how we feel . Yeah , I hate the puttons . We should get merched . That says that the fucking puttons .
Speaker 2But anyway . So there you have it , wanderers . Good afternoon , good evening and good night , and we're all going to bed . Good night , Good night .
Speaker 1Thanks for listening today . The show wouldn't be possible without our amazing producer and editor , Rob Fitzpatrick , who works tirelessly behind the scenes to bring you the best content .
Speaker 2And a special thanks to Tyga Soundprod for providing the captivating intro music . Cinematic intro 24 .
Speaker 1And of course , we can't forget the hauntingly beautiful outro music , Rhino's Theme , composed by Kevin MacLeod .
Speaker 2If you enjoyed today's episode , make sure to leave a rating and review on your favorite podcast platforms like Spotify , apple and YouTube . Your feedback means the world to us .
Speaker 1Also be sure to follow us on Instagram for behind the scenes glimpses , updates and more thrilling content . You can find us at Wicked Wandering's Podcast .
Speaker 2Thank you so much for listening and being part of our Wicked Wandering's community . We appreciate each and every one of you . Stay curious .
Speaker 1Keep exploring and always remember to keep on wandering .
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Music City 911
Music City 911