Wicked Wanderings
Delve into the enigmatic realms of the mysterious, unearth tales of haunting encounters, explore the chilling depths of true crime, and unravel the threads of the unexplained. Join us on the Wicked Wanderings Podcast for a riveting journey through the realms of the unknown and the haunting mysteries that linger in the shadows.
Wicked Wanderings
Ep. 13: Mental Health from 1800s to WWI
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this eye-opening episode of Wicked Wanderings, we embark on a historical exploration of mental health from the 1800s to the early 1900s, spanning a transformative period in societal attitudes and treatment practices. Join us as Jonathan rejoins the conversation, adding depth to our understanding of this fascinating yet often dark chapter in history.
We'll delve into the evolving perspectives on mental health during this time, examining societal beliefs, treatment methods, and the experiences of individuals grappling with mental health challenges. From the advent of asylums to changing perceptions influenced by medical, social, and cultural factors, this episode unravels the complex tapestry of mental health history.
Subscribe now to join us on this captivating journey through time, as we shed light on the shadows of the past and explore the crucial intersections between history, mental health, and the human experience.
Shadows in the Valley: A Cultural History of Illness, Death, and Loss in New England, 1840-1916 by Alan Swedlund
Mad In America: Bad Science, Bad Medicine, And The Enduring Mistreatment Of The Mentally Ill by Robert Whitaker
If you'd like to show your support for Wicked Wanderings and join our community of dedicated listeners, you can start contributing for as little as $3 a month. Your support helps us continue to explore the darkest and most intriguing mysteries, bringing you captivating stories from the world of true crime and the unexplained. Click the link to become a valued member of our podcast family.
Don't forget to rate, review, and follow us on your favorite streaming platform.
Wicked Wanderings Website
Linktree
Instagram
We'd love to hear from you!
Email us @ wickedwanderingspodcast@gmail.com
Text Us @ CLICK HERE
Wicked Wanderings is hosted by Hannah & Courtney and it's produced by Rob Fitzpatrick. Music by Sascha Ende.
Wicked Wanderings is a Production of Studio 113
Mental Asylums
Speaker 1All right , we ready do ?
Speaker 2I'm gonna turn it off and turn it on again .
Speaker 3No , sorry , yeah , he can edit .
Speaker 1Hello wanderers . I'm Hannah and I'm Jess , and this is Wicked Wanderings , Hello Jess .
Speaker 3Hello Hannah , hi John .
Speaker 2Hello .
Speaker 3We are so excited to have you back .
Speaker 1Thank you for inviting me back always you've been asked for . So , yes , no one listens to us unless you're here now .
Speaker 2That is not true .
Speaker 1We need to put him on an intermittent schedule , because then it's kind of like gambling .
Speaker 3It's like yeah , no one's gonna . Yes , it's the most effective Conditioning right . Yes , it is actually .
Speaker 1I will be honest and say I'm not sure where I'm going with my episodes . This time I Want to talk about asylums and their histories , as well as the hauntings that have been recorded . But with my background in psychology and working in the mental health field , I also want to give a background on what mental health was like back then and where it is now Hopefully different . Also , we both know it is . I think it is important to understand the history of how individuals with mental health were treated in these facilities , because they don't also help us understand why they are still haunting some of those locations still . Mm-hmm right .
Speaker 1So , during this , I want to talk about the different methods that were used , that were inhumane treatments and Downright fucking terrible ways to treat human beings , and , while I do not know where this episode or episodes are going , I hope you will all come in the ride with me . I also want to add a trigger warning to this episode , because some of the things I talk about are hard to hear and the way people were treated were inhumane and important . It is , however , important to know our history in order to not repeat it . So are we all good with that ? I'm down , okay .
Speaker 2I'm on board .
Speaker 1So we're gonna start in 1751 , where the Quakers helped petition for a hospital to help with people with mental disabilities . But there was also another reason why they were doing this . In 1756 , the hospital was established and it was basically a jail for those who live there to protect the community from them and , by the way , so that the Quakers were the first ones to build a mental hospital , which I thought was very interesting .
Speaker 2And where is this ?
Speaker 1This was in Pennsylvania , I thought it might be in Pennsylvania .
Speaker 3Yeah , at least it's not the Puritans . So I have to say damn fucking ampartnom .
Speaker 1The hospital was then treated like a sideshow for the public . They would go and gawk at the people who were there and would get them riled up , especially the individuals that were chained In 1760 . Offense was put up around the facility , but this did not stop the public . The hospital then decided they might as well charge people a fee to come and see their patients . So the public was then charged for Pence to enter . That's so messed up , isn't that terrible ? So they were basically a sideshow for the public . That's like , oh , sunday afternoon after church let's go poke at people .
Speaker 2But that was not unusual . You hear stories like the hospital that they later termed . I think was Bethlehem Hospital , but they called it Bedlam Hospital . Might not be getting my facts right , but that was like the original Place in London where you could go and gawk at people , whether they were prisoners or they were Mentally handicapped or just deranged or a mixture of those . So it was common in England . I'm not surprised it came to the colonies Dr Benjamin Rush came to the hospital in 1783 he was known as the father of American psychiatry .
Speaker 1Rush came into the hospital hoping to reform . Rush was a signer of the Declaration of Independence . He advocated to abolish slavery and prison reform . Rush got a new wing put into Pennsylvania Hospital , where patients were given nicer beds and areas to live . He allowed patients that had quote good behavior To be able to walk the halls , attend classes of sewing and such . He provided typical companions to encourage friendship and social skills . While this is all progressive thinking for the time , the men in the field that Rush knew about and associated with also had different ideals for healing or fixing the mentally ill .
Speaker 3So really this is like the beginnings of behavior modification , in a sense Reinforcement for your good behavior .
Speaker 1Yeah , I think we've had that through history . It's just for some reason ABA gave it a name . No , they wanted to make it cool yeah , I guess so .
Speaker 1Scientists were stating that , in order to make these people less unruly , that beating them until they are submissive or fainting is the way to go , they would give them such things as mercury to induce vomiting , so the patients would not have energy to have episodes . These scientists justified what they were doing by saying that , because the patients were thinking of the pain , it took their mind off the ranting and raving they usually engaged in oh my god , this is horrible already . Oh , it gets worse . They also starved the patients as a way to keep them quiet .
Speaker 1Another method was called blistering . They would rub mustard powder on shaped scalps and the blistered powder would be used to make them less unruly . And the blisters were formed and then they rubbed another item , causing severe pain and infection . And this would also cause the patient to rub in other areas , causing severe pain . So like they rubbed there , they end up rubbing other places and one doctor said this helped the patient come back to his true self and remember who he really was .
Speaker 3Is this like the same stuff , like mustard gas ? What do you mean ? Like they mustard gas , the biological warfare ?
Speaker 1Oh , like it could be , I don't know , because later on I 'll actually Get into how we add a big influence on what the Nazis did in Germany . Oh okay , we were not innocent . No uh , you think , oh , we were the allies with a good , especially when it came to the gas chambers . It kind of actually started here in America , went over . I mean granted , hitler took it to a whole new , other level .
Speaker 3Yeah , I figure the only the good person is whoever writes history .
Speaker 1Yeah anyway continue because of these horrific treatments these individuals were given the patients , but only have to see certain staff and cower away because they did not want what happened before To happen to them , so like if whoever inflicted the pain on them , if they just saw them , they would just like clam up , which is with any trauma or abuse victim .
Speaker 3I was gonna say PTSD right there .
Speaker 1Exactly the mere sight of certain staff quieted them and caused them to be frightened . In 18th century there were mad houses for the elite . So let's say you're tired of your wife . She doesn't necessarily have to have done anything wrong , but you have noticed she is speaking up for herself , or maybe having an individual thought . God forbid .
Speaker 3Do not get me started .
Speaker 2I know you said 18th century and I don't mean to fast forward , but Commodore Vanderbilt , 19th century founder of the Vanderbilt fortune , put his wife . He would basically put his wife in and out of asylums For silly things , like she didn't want to move from Staten Island to Manhattan .
Speaker 3Oh , my god .
Speaker 2So these were used with . I mean people who should be treated by medical professionals were put into these asylums , but also people used it as A threat in control out of people who were Totally normal .
Speaker 1We actually ended up talking about the Rockefellers later on . So it's like these huge men and families that were in power . They were using their money for just Whatever . Well , I would consider sinful things .
Speaker 3Do you get into the hysteria ?
Speaker 1So I will say that what I'm covering in this episode only goes so far . Okay , but if you think that I've passed that part of time , feel free .
Speaker 3Well , honestly , I don't know much about it , but it's like stuff like that , like women standing up for themselves or being moody , or you know , it's that time of the month .
Speaker 1We better put them in the mental institution and I think if our listeners know us at all , they'll know how feminist we are , I'm true . So , like I said , like if you're , you know , if your wife is just not talking the way you want her to , you go to the doctor . The doctor agrees with you , you pay the doctor for his time and the madhouse pays the doctor for his referral . And if you are a doctor who owns the madhouse , even better , you get double paid . There was actually a man named William Batty who left an estate ranging from a hundred to 200,000 pounds because of this trade , which nowadays would be in the millions .
Speaker 2Wow .
Speaker 1I know , so different water therapies were introduced . And this is not you know what your grandma does at the Jewish community center or YMCA , dunking heads in water , blindfolding patients . So they fell into a vat of water .
Speaker 1So water that bath is a water bathing or , you know , like a form of torture , where they stick their head underwater waterboarding waterboarding , thank you , throwing patients into the sea so they almost drown , putting a box with holes on their head and it's immersing them in water . One gentleman invented a cage that the patient would be put in and then lowered into water . A chair was then invented that would swivel a person at high speeds , causing vomiting , defecating , indoor dizziness and beds go ahead .
Speaker 3Well , I'm just wondering what their thought process was Like . How did they think this was going to heal I don't think . Well , maybe that's the thing is , they didn't think it was going to heal them , it was just to manage their behavior . Okay , I just answered my own question .
Speaker 1Beds were also made to swivel at high speeds , and a machine where they could put more than one patient at a time was also made , so it was basically looked like a ride you would see at a carnival , but they would just spin them until , basically , oh , my God their brain is mush .
Speaker 3No , thanks yeah .
Speaker 1Getting back to Rush in the States , though , he was a Quaker and he seemed to have humane ideas . He was an educated man , who actually educated at the University of Edinburgh and also wanting to follow in the footsteps of his counterparts across the pond , which this is not a good thing . Let's also think about the amount of proclaimed doctors in America which wasn't America yet , by the way , obviously , but what we know as America to think about how many of them actually had , how many of them actually had educations . So fewer than 5% had degrees and about 10% had actual training . So this reminds me of the witch trials , where Jess pointed out several times , I believe , that these men did not even have theological training or law training and they were messing with people's lives .
Speaker 3Yes , also , like IDs weren't a thing , certificates weren't a thing , you could go anywhere and be like oh , I'm a doctor in practice , without zero training . All you had was your charisma to prove that you knew what you were doing .
Speaker 2I'm reading a wonderful book and I know we're still in the 18th century , but the book is called Shadows in the Valley A Cultural History of Illness , death and Lost in New England 1840-1916 , which of course is ahead of what you're talking about . But and the author's name is Alan Swedlund I'm sorry if I butchered that last name . Fabulous book . I'm only halfway through , but Alan gives really wonderful context into where we were in this period of time in medical history . And I mean you're already talking about how so few actually had training . Alan does the exact same thing . He sets the stage and says most of these people had never been to a college for medicine . We were really lucky and you had a really good physician if they'd had some sort of internship for a year . And then we're set loose . So this trend continues . It doesn't end at the 18th century , it goes straight through until the end of the 19th .
Speaker 3What was the name of the book ?
Speaker 2It's called Shadows in the Valley . In the Valley . It's a great book .
Speaker 3Adding to cart .
Speaker 2It's very medical heavy , but it's good .
Speaker 3So on a good cognitive day .
Speaker 1Yes , rush had similar beliefs like his counterparts across the pond , that madness was caused by morbid and irregular actions in the blood vessels of the brain . I'm going to quote from Robert Whitaker's book Madden America Some of the reasons this irregularity would happen , according to Rush . So here I quote an injury to the brain , too much labor , extreme weather , worms , consumption , constipation , masturbation , intense study and too much imagination so pretty much I'd be tortured .
Speaker 3Basically is what this is .
Speaker 1I mean , that's a normal day . Right Rush was proud of his invention called the tranquilizer chair . Do you think this sounds like a good invention ?
Speaker 2I'm nervous .
Speaker 1Probably not . He would bound patients in a seated position so they could not move , and place a wooden contraption on their head so they could not see . And a bowl with a hole in the chair was placed underneath so patients could go into the bathroom , because they would be in the chair for long periods of time .
Speaker 3I mean , at least he's thinking of that . Wow , you're fired . I'm just kidding . I had high hopes for Benjamin .
Speaker 1Rush . Rush became famous in the field , causing other physicians to use his invention , and one study left his patient in it for six months .
Speaker 3Six months , six months , okay , no , yeah , yeah , benjamin .
Speaker 1Another movement occurred where other physicians were starting to use the water therapy , the spinning therapy and Rush's invention . A Dr Willard who had a small madhouse on the border of Massachusetts , emerald Island , had a tank made on premise that he would use on patients . He would put them in a coffin-like box with holes and dunk them in the tank . When the bubbles ceased , he pulled them and revived them . He is quoted to say he did this quote to break the patient's will and make him learn that he had a master and quote oh my God , that would freak me out .
Speaker 3I have a fear of drowning and being confined in small places . I would die .
Speaker 1I just I think of the people and the kids I work with right now . It bothers me to the core and it irks me like nothing else that this stuff was happening . But it was normal . And then I start thinking , all right , what is normal in our life ? Now that I'm accepting that I'm not doing anything about ?
Speaker 3Yeah , you know what I mean , that , I know my core that I'm not okay with . Yeah , I have comments about that , but I feel like you're gonna get there later , so it's okay , if you have a comment you want to tell me . Well , it was . It was just going to talk about residential placements now , as opposed to like asylums and the lack of resources that the mental health field has .
Speaker 1I'm sure we'll get there . Yeah , I really don't get past World War Two during this episode , but okay . Yeah .
Speaker 3I'm very opinionated about that and you guys will find out why .
Reforming Mental Health Treatment
Speaker 1There was a man named Penel . I don't know what it is . It's P-I-N-E-L . Penel Penel . He's from France . Penel , penel Penel . There's no A though .
Speaker 2It's P-I-N-A-L and .
Speaker 1E-L Penel Penel .
Speaker 2We can move past this , mr P .
Speaker 1Yes , there's a man named Mr P from France and a group of English Quakers that both started reforming the way the mentally ill were treated . Mr P reformed hospitals so that patients were treated more like people unless like animals . Wow , it felt so novel . Amazing , the Quakers made their own place for the mentally ill to come , where they had tea parties and friendship . It is nice to see that not everyone back then was an asshole . Fun fact the first public asylum so for us lowly people and not the rich was founded in Worcester , massachusetts , in 1833 . Well shit , look at that . So the Quakers had theirs , but obviously it wasn't a public one because they were the first ones . But the first public one was in Worcester .
Speaker 3Are you sure ? It's not Orchester .
Speaker 2No .
Speaker 3Sorry , just kidding . Sorry , jonathan , I interrupted .
Speaker 2I knew what I was gonna ask what was the name of the asylum ?
Speaker 1I talk about it later on . I'm pretty sure I talk about it later on .
Speaker 2Because Massachusetts has a bunch that .
Speaker 1And I actually looked it up because it's not there anymore . But there's actually some really beautiful pictures because Worcester has like a historical foundation or whatever and I looked it up and they have some beautiful pictures of it .
Speaker 3Okay idea . I know you are the king of the spooky weekends . Yes , However mental asylums of New England .
Speaker 2I would get on that bus tour .
Speaker 3Wouldn't that be awesome , okay , sorry .
Speaker 2Love it .
Speaker 1Just putting that out there the idea of the wanted asylum , a reward , good behavior by letting you pick your room , strolling about the grounds and even going into town on occasion , as long as you came back in time and no drinking . Restraining was a last resort . They were given cutlery to eat and even hosted a ball with the public With . This . Movement towards humane treatment also meant that there was no use for physicians . Some of these hospitals were started by Quakers and they did not want physicians coming in and trying out the latest in humane fat on their patients . The boards consisted of non-physicians or physicians who lost belief in these physical treatments . Doctors were noticing that their position in mental care was becoming non-existent , with success rates of patients going up . Go figure , treat them like humans , and then they'll improve .
Speaker 1And this is why doctors started to golf . I'm just kidding , I'm just Faking that up With this . Doctors were not going to let this happen without a fight . Now I do wanna add that I am not against doctors . I want to make that clear . I think medicine has come far , but there's always room for improvement . These guys as my colleague just puts it , our douche canoes , acylums . Acylums were using chemical restraints like opium and morphine . Because of this , it led to the use of physical restraints as a straight jacket , due to how crowded these facilities were getting . Utica Luna took asylum in New York , used a crib-like structure that had a lid with a hinge that they would leave patients in . Imagine the claustrophobia this would cause . In 1844 , the association made it official that the use of physical restraints was for the bettering of humanity .
Speaker 3Sorry , I can go off right now , but I'll still wait .
Speaker 2Speak your anchor .
Speaker 3Okay , so if you want me to tell my story now , because it includes restraints , so the agency I used to work for that I will not name , had a separate part of it , because if I say that separate part , it will be known to people who read the news . They would improperly restrain the clients there and lock them indoors if they were getting like in a padded room , if they were getting escalated , whatever . When you have children with trauma who experience that and who have triggered from being touched , that starts a whole another layer to that trauma , right , and so it adds on to all the layers . And so the agency was actually . There's lawsuits against them for the improperly restrained .
Speaker 3But that's also a thing with the mental health field nowadays is they hire people at minimum wage and then pay them little for as much as they deal with right , and they don't invest in their employees , and so they leave . There's high turnover , they don't train them , and so if they don't train them , then they're being negligent , in my opinion , as an agency , right . And so the reason I am so like against this shit is because I don't know my Utah people may know I have a sister that's low functioning autistic and she's four years younger than me , and my mom is getting older . She can't handle physically my sister anymore , and so they ended up having to put my sister in a home like a residential placement , and the first night there the neighbor complained because my sister became dysregulated . And when they get so dysregulated like that , I mean you know , hannah , there is no way to talk them out of it . Right talk is probably the worst thing to do , yeah .
Speaker 3And so they called the police . The neighbors called the police and a police officer responded and put my sister in handcuffs . Oh , and cognitively she's like five or six years old . She doesn't understand what was going on , Right , and so it made her freak out more .
Speaker 3And then they have these people in the homes where my mom would pick Amy her name's Amy pick her up on the weekends , and she would come with bruises and a black eye . And the staff told my mom that she hit herself hard enough to give herself a black eye . And I'm like , okay , mom , if in the 30 years that you've raised Amy , have you ever seen her hit herself so hard to give her a black eye ? She's like , no , I haven't . And I'm like well , there you go . And if she is hitting herself that hard , then that's a whole nother issue that she's starting self harm after 30 years of not engaging . Right , I think , these residential placements some of them , not all of them who have a lack of training , lack of income , lack of resources for the mental health field , it's just not as bad as what you've been talking about , but there's still shit going on .
Speaker 1And even to speak on the officer you talked about , they don't have any training on how to deal with this , no population . So to put her in handcuffs . That's just traumatizing her more Because she wasn't a harm to the community . No Right , she's not a criminal , so doing that was unnecessary . But to the person's defense , they probably didn't know what else to do . Yeah .
Speaker 3I mean cause she's a big girl and flailing her arms . But no , they wrong , wrong approach . Anyway , I'll get off my soapbox .
Speaker 1Poor Amy . I know there were , however , facilities like Pennsylvania Hospital for the insane in the mid to late 1800s that was known for their moral treatment , and these people had hotel like spaces to sleep . They dressed appropriately for the time , they had a library parlor and even entertainment where shows came in . The staff were interviewed and references checked to make sure that they would treat the patients with human dignity . Unfortunately , not all facilities could be like this , especially the public ones , and when public assignments were made , like the Worcester one , corners were cut . There was no parlor or outsider detainment . Funding Pay was low , as with many state run places , and so people got hired off the street with no need for references or character checks . Old ways of dealing with the patients were returning , and so the same here when we talk about even the public school system . Like you have families that can afford to put their children in private school systems , and then you have other people that can be left behind just because of status and where you're from . So times haven't changed .
Speaker 3Not really . I mean , to some extent , yes , but the same problems keep showing themselves , but in different ways .
Speaker 1You're really quiet . I wanna make sure that you don't wanna add anything .
Speaker 2No , no , it's a lot to process . I think I'm just processing through it .
Speaker 1Okay , no problem , we are going to start going into the 1900s , where I wanna start by reading this quote from the book that I talked about , mad America , by Robert Whitaker , which I highly recommend . So in here I quote in a stream of scientific articles , newspaper editorials and popular books , the mentally ill were described as a degenerate strain of humanity , social wastage that bred in alarming rates and burdened normal Americans with the great expense of paying for their upkeep . America's embrace of that notion led to a wholesale societal assault on the severely mentally ill . They were prohibited from marrying in many states , forcibly committed to state hospitals and even ever greater numbers , and then a number of states sterilized against their will . America's Genesis even encouraged Nazi Germany in its massive sterilization of the mentally ill , a program that led directly to the crematoriums of the Holocaust .
Eugenics and Asylum Hauntings
Speaker 3I don't know if it's just my sister or the Smirnoffs , it's just making me so angry .
Speaker 1Maybe , both . When I read that , I literally like verbal like what ? Yeah ? Like where is this book going and what is it trying to tell me ? And then we're gonna start talking about eugenics and it . This is stuff they don't tell you in his at least not in my history classes that I remember , you know . We're like we were the allies , what the fuck . Like that's what I'm saying we had a huge influence .
Speaker 3It , it , it irks me so bad , but this is going to be a three hour long episode because we're just going to talk about all the injustices and anger we're experiencing right now as mental health providers .
Speaker 1Charles Darwin's cousin , sir Francis Galton , developed a term called eugenics , which means well born . His philosophy was that in order to make a high society , we have to breed accordingly . I am putting this very simply , but basically , unless you are white , intelligent and well bred , then you should not have the right to procreate . In America , the individuals who are funding this type of research were people like Andrew Carnegie and John D Rockefeller Jr . Wow , which for some reason that boggled my mind .
Speaker 3Just because you have money doesn't mean you're smart .
Speaker 1Right , due to the influx of immigration . The wasps right , white Inglesacks and Protestants of America were blaming insanity on the immigrants such as the Irish , which bothered me obviously .
Speaker 3Because I'm not explains a lot about my husband Just kidding , and I can say that because he doesn't listen . Oh , that's right , you are a goon in . I forgot that .
Speaker 1There was a great push to put the mentally ill and asylums and sterilize as well as castrate . Racism and hate was a driving force in all of this because , depending on where you were from or where your family was originally dependent on the crimes you would commit . So there is basically a section in there where he was like if you're Irish , these are the things you're accused of . If you're Portuguese , these are the things you're accused of .
Speaker 3It's like what Discrimination at its finest right .
Speaker 1And one of the crimes that the Irish were accused of is too much procreating .
Speaker 3They were mad that you're making too many babies Like what . That's a prep . Go ahead , Jonathan .
Speaker 2Sorry , I just want to underscore something you said before , which was about to put it simply in the least in the United States , talking 19th century , why did eugenics catch on so quickly ? And of course , part of it is just curiosity about innovations in medical science and medicine overall , but also it is a huge response to massive waves of immigration coming in . And I would also add you talked about the wasp who are basically funding all of this . It's not just immigration , but it's also religion . There was a huge fear in the 19th century that with these new immigrants coming in , so many of them were Roman Catholics , that it would tip the tide of religion in the United States .
Speaker 2Yeah , very true so we can go into a hole about what they were afraid of with the Irish or the Portuguese , as you've already mentioned , but just kind of as a general cast , they were afraid of immigrants . They were afraid that the Roman Catholics would take over .
Speaker 1Yeah , absolutely Very good point . So , jess , yes , what is all of this reminding you of Hitler ?
Speaker 2Yeah , I think you kind of alluded to that before .
Speaker 1I skipped ahead . Yes , I feel , at least from my experience . We do not talk about how this idea was discussed and researched here in America . I did not know the extent to which these things were happening here in the States and so I'm actually going to quote again because I am actually really in love with this book . It's really good . So I'm going to quote from out in America again because , honestly , like when I'm researching and , jess , I'm sure you can attest sometimes you can't paraphrase .
Speaker 3Yeah , you just need to write it all down .
Speaker 1Yeah , it's just there's no point paraphrasing , because it's what is ? Being said is the best way to read it . So the committee to study and to report on the best practical means of cutting off the defective germplasm in the American population calculated that 10% of the American population was defective and should be sterilized . It was an agenda that pleased former president Theodore Roosevelt , which I did not know because now I don't like Theodore Roosevelt At present . He wrote the committee there is no check to the fegundity of those who are subnormal .
Speaker 2Well done .
Speaker 1Thank you . That was a hard word for me today , during a national eugenics conference that year , funded by John Harvey Kellogg , inventor of the flake cereal , the scope of the needed enterprise was further defined over the next 40 years , the country need to sterilize 5.76 million Americans in order to reduce the percentage of defectives in the population to an acceptable level . And I just want to say so now . Every time you have that bowl of corn flakes in the morning , you can think how this man tried furthering the future of eugenics and has the mass genocide of millions . Boycott corn flakes , boycott corn flakes .
Speaker 2They're not delicious anyway , so I don't think any of us would miss it if we did .
Speaker 1Nope , I hereby boycott and Kellogg corn flakes . I forgot about boycotts . Can we put that on our sweatshirts ?
Speaker 3Boycott , boycott , kellogg .
Speaker 1I just want to reiterate here that I'm trying to build up to talking about individual asylums and hauntings . I just want our people to know that , but personally , I believe it is important to talk about what was happening during these times In order to understand what these patients were going through . We need to understand what was happening in history and what they were hearing from doctors , nurses , staff and other patients . I think it would be impossible for these patients not to hear about this movement of eugenics being pushed in society that they were hearing . They were worthless and should be thrown away like garbage . Like you can't tell me , these people were in asylums and not hearing staff talk about this . Right , that's horrible . When people go into these asylums and they do these haunting trips , don't you want to understand why they're still hanging around ?
Speaker 3It's been a space full of trauma , no wonder .
Speaker 1So here I am quoting again the society focused on promoting eugenics to the American public , getting textbooks and pamphlets into schools and conducting informational campaigns to build support for sterilization laws . One of its popular traveling exhibits , consisting of a board with blinking lights , was titled Some People Are Born to Be a Burden on the Rest . Every 15 seconds , a light flashed to warn onlookers that American taxpayers had just spent another $100 caring for defectives . Every 30 seconds , a light flashed to signal that another defective had been born . At intervals of 50 seconds , a flashing light told of another criminal being carted off to prison , with the audience informed that very few normal persons ever go to jail . Finally , after seven and one-and-a-half long minutes , a light blinked to announce that a high-grade person at long last had been born .
Speaker 3All I have to say is fuck that shit . Thank you , Jonathan .
Speaker 2What I'm kind of curious about is that I mean , we talk about people who are genuinely mentally ill who are being factored in , and we mentioned a little bit about women particularly being thrown in just for Having a big imagination , or or you know yes . What other kinds of people who we wouldn't consider now as Needing additional medical attention , like I know that persons who were LGBTQ is all you are also considered mentally defective at this period of time . Are there other groups of people who have been factored into this ?
Speaker 1So I hear what you're saying . So they did talk a lot about Individuals with schizophrenia or a bipolar , which we would still consider a mental illness , now individuals with depression . I'm sure there was a lot of women that had melancholy .
Speaker 3I think they referred to it back then like postpartum depression .
Speaker 1I think of my kiddos with autism that just think and learn a little bit differently , but I'm thinking of , like my heavy-hitter kids that would be put in this . So I understand what you're saying . Like , how many of these people would we not consider mentally ill ? I think it's a good question .
Speaker 2I think my other question is and maybe I'm just completely going down a rabbit path , but we talk a lot about the Asylums in the Northeast . Did they have the same kind of network of asylums in the south ?
Speaker 1Not that I read so far . Now yeah , I mean grant , I haven't finished my book .
Speaker 3I haven't finished my research , so I'm sure , there are some things I just haven't gotten to yet well , and I think what we see is people that come along with good intentions , and it starts well , but then the funding disappears and so it becomes more of survival out of Necessity rather than healing with good intentions . I mean , I don't have a specific case , but it just seems like that's the same old story of these mental asylums . Is that it's all started with people who want to make Change and help people , and then , yeah , overcrowding yeah for sure , I think that's such a good point .
Eugenics and Nazi Germany's Influence
Speaker 1I do also want to bring the point that they even got the church involved and I am gonna quote again to get the country's clergy involved , the AES , which was the community that they actually named a Sponsored annual contest with cash awards up to $500 for ministers and priests who delivered the best eugenics sermon . So in 1928 Reverend William Mattson of the Methodist Episcopal Church Won the top prize of $500 by telling his congregation that quote modern science had proven all men are created unequal .
Speaker 3Okay , so it goes against Constitution .
Speaker 1Oh and then he also said we may raise a pig in the parlor , but he remains a pig . And what year was this ? This was 1928 , was not long ago .
Speaker 2I don't doubt that there's a lot of racism Also factored into that . Yes . That's also the period of time of white nationalism and I'm trying to remember that awful movie that Woodrow Wilson loved Super racist . I know this goes off topic .
Speaker 1No , it's okay .
Speaker 2Oh gosh , it's like the Ku Klux Klan movie . I'll figure it out and I'll come back . Okay , by the way , I don't doubt that Calling up the pig in the parlor and talking about not all people are created equal is definitely wound up in the same giant , eugenics , racism . You know , white people first , white nationalism idea all at once .
Speaker 3This is what happens when you mix religion , politics and mental health . Yeah , but that's a whole nother episode .
Speaker 1The supreme court in 1927 ruled that sterilization was constitutional and by the end of 1945 45,127 americans have been sterilized under these laws and 21,311 of those people were patients in state mental hospitals , against their will , most of them . Mm-hmm .
Speaker 1They were given away their options like just taken away , like just . Something that really made my head spin was that America had a huge influence on eugenics in Germany and the start of Hitler , hitler's regime . So I'm gonna bounce around a little bit again . I'm reading from Madden America Great book America's influence on Nazi Germany was particularly pronounced and it was in that country , of course , that eugenics ran full course . Prior to World War one , eugenics was not nearly as popular in Germany as it was in the United States . In 1925 , adolf Hitler In I don't speak German , sorry in Menkamp , mine Come mine , thank you guys Hailed eugenics as the science of a rebuild . The nation , the state , he wrote , must quote avail itself of modern medical discoveries and sterilize those patients who are unfit for procreation .
Speaker 2So for background , hannah , if you're not familiar or maybe some of the readers aren't familiar with mine , come , it's his personal doctrine . It's his Magnus opi or opi . I've heard of it but , like I , I didn't know what it was the central tenant of what Hitler believed . Ah well , there you go . Thank you , jonathan . See , this is why we keep them around .
Speaker 1That's why we love John .
Speaker 2I know these little segments of information .
Speaker 1After Hitler came to power in 1933 , germany passed a comprehensive sterilization bill . The German eugenics who drew up that legislation had gone to school on the US Experience , which American eugenics eugenics , excuse me noted with some pride . The leaders in the German sterilization movement state repeatedly that their legislation was formulated only after careful study of the California experiments . And this was the person who wrote . That was Margaret Smith , who was superintendent of Stockton State Hospital after touring Germany in 1935 . So it was American . And she also said it would have been impossible , they say , to undertake such a venture involving 1 million people without drawing heavily upon previous Experience elsewhere . What the fuck ? Excuse my French .
Speaker 2Really heavy .
Speaker 3I think that's more redneck than French .
Speaker 1Oh , okay .
Speaker 3That works Just kidding .
Speaker 1This idea of merciful killings started as well . Where this idea of if you aren't going to get better , let's just kill you by poison ?
Speaker 3I mean that's for horses who break a leg Like , not for human beings .
Speaker 1The caseloads of the doctors were incredibly large over 100 patients per doctor . Sometimes patients would not see a doctor for a year . The attendance in these hospitals were underpaid compared to people working in state prisons and the fact that they were left to their own devices with these patients . They became creative in the way they managed . Quote order . So I'm actually going to read a snippet . That's in Mad America , but it's what woman Marl Woodson's own experience was , because she was a newspaper reporter who was hospitalized in an Oklahoma asylum for a while , and this is her own words Wet toweling a patient is choking him unconscious by getting a wet towel around his neck and twisting on it from the back until he succumbs .
Speaker 1Sometimes a pillow slip is used instead of a towel . Soaping a man down means knocking him down with a slug made of a hard bar of soap in the toe of a sock . Such a slug will knock a patient down after rendering him unconscious without leaving telltale marks . The wet towel treatment also leaves no marks or scars for inquisitive officials , hospital authorities or unexpected visitors to find Her raw . For the inventive genius of younger America . It finds ways to make itself safe , which I feel like that's a lot of sarcasm .
Speaker 3That she was , I wouldn't hope so , but this is like . This is abuse . It's abuse , this is abuse . This is something that would get you or I fired . Yeah , right now .
Speaker 1Which is comforting .
Speaker 1Yes , but at the same time this is ridiculous that they thought this would help and so in the 1930s , american Medical Association actually hired a young physician named John Grimes and they wanted him to do like surveys throughout 174 state hospitals , to kind of be like , all right , what's happening in these places ? Cause we can't , we don't know what's going on in all of them . So he ended up sending out surveys and visiting almost all of them and he wrote up this whole thing that just basically talks about . You know how it looks beautiful from the outside . They keep up the grounds and then you get into these places and it's it's overcrowded . They're in dining rooms and hallways where Cots are . That's where they should be eating and hanging out .
Speaker 1And he even found instances of disturbed patients having to sleep to a bed . A tendency said , acted like prison guards . Wards were locked in , the windows barred . As for feeding the patients , the hospitals often had to rely on what could be reaped from their own farms . So eggs were a rare delicacy , few could give them milk and they served to confine people unwanted by society , including many who are not mentally ill but were there because of unsocial or antisocial manifestations . So you're socially awkward , you're going here . And the worst part is he wrote up this whole thing for the MAA and they told him to change his report . He refused and they fired him . Of course they did , and then he ended up having this published on his own , but no one would listen to him , and I'm leaving on that good note .
Speaker 1This just makes me so angry I know I've been so angry but , like I said earlier , I think this will give us a good background and so when we are talking about these hauntings , we can kind of understand these people a little bit more and why some of them are stuck .
Speaker 3Yeah , I can imagine .
Speaker 1They weren't treated nicely and maybe why some of them killed themselves , you know , because how could you live with that ? Yeah , for sure .
Speaker 2Yeah , really good context , if really sobering .
Speaker 1Yeah , I know it's , I know it's a lot , but I'm actually kind of , I'm mostly enjoying . I am intrigued , yes , about the history and realizing that , yes , we are doing better in the mental health field , but we can do more better . There's also a lot of work . There is a lot of work More trauma-informed , care is definitely needed .
Speaker 3Yes , Also , do you get into lobotomies ? Oh girl , I am so excited for lobotomies . We can totally talk about Rose Kennedy .
Speaker 2Yes .
Speaker 3Right , oh , John's like yes . That is exactly where I went .
Speaker 2Mm-hmm Whole episode on the Kennedys .
Speaker 1Oh yeah , honestly , we should do a whole episode on the Kennedys because they're very bam . Yeah . Well , a lot of stuff has happened to the Kennedys . They're probably .
Speaker 3Well , they are from Massachusetts , so I can see them in 1692 being the Puttnams and hanging on people for the rest of their lives .
Speaker 1So , thank you all for coming on this journey with me . Yes , until next time , bye , bye .
Speaker 2Bye .
Speaker 1Thanks for listening today . The show wouldn't be possible without our amazing producer and editor , Rob Fitzpatrick , who works tirelessly behind the scenes to bring you the best content .
Speaker 3And a special thanks to Tyga Soundprod for providing the captivating intro music . Cinematic intro 24 .
Speaker 1And of course , we can't forget the hauntingly beautiful outro music , Rhino's Theme , composed by Kevin MacLeod .
Speaker 3If you enjoyed today's episode , make sure to leave a rating and review on your favorite podcast platforms like Spotify , apple and YouTube . Your feedback means the world to us .
Speaker 1Also be sure to follow us on Instagram for behind the scenes , splimpses , updates and more thrilling content . You can find us at Wicked Wandering's Podcast .
Speaker 3Thank you so much for listening and being part of our Wicked Wandering's community .
Speaker 4We appreciate each and every one of you Stay curious , keep exploring and always remember to keep on wandering .
People on this episode
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Music City 911
Music City 911